Calculation of Total Tone-to-Noise Ratio and Total Prominence Ratio for Small Fan Noise and Determination of Subjective Annoyance Thresholds

Fan noise from small cooling fans often contains multiple coexisting tonal components whose combined perceptual impact cannot be fully represented by conventional single-tone metrics. While the Tone-to-Noise Ratio (TNR) and Prominence Ratio (PR) defined in ECMA-418-1 are established measures for evaluating individual tonal components, their direct application under multi-tone conditions may be insufficient to characterize cumulative tonal influence. To address this issue, the Total Tone-to-Noise Ratio (TTNR) and the Total Prominence Ratio (TPR) have been proposed as cumulative extensions of the ECMA framework. In this study, calculation procedures for TTNR and TPR were systematically examined for projector operating noise containing multiple tonal components, and subjective annoyance thresholds were determined using controlled jury ranking tests with 20 participants. Detection parameters for tonal extraction were adjusted within the ECMA-418-1 framework to reflect realistic product conditions. The resulting annoyance thresholds were 11.6 dB for TTNR and 14.3 dB for TPR. These findings indicate that cumulative tonal evaluation can be performed within the existing standardized framework and that TTNR and TPR provide practical tools for assessing multi-tone noise in technical products equipped with small cooling fans.