Empirical Validation of Fitts’ Law in Virtual Reality: Modeling, Prediction, and Modality Comparison

Fitts’ law is a foundational model for predicting pointing performance and has been increasingly explored in immersive virtual reality (VR) environments. This paper presents a controlled experimental framework for deriving modality-specific Fitts’ law models in VR and evaluating their predictive transfer to applied interaction tasks. The framework comprises two scenarios. The first replicates a standardized ISO 9241 pointing task in a 3D virtual environment to derive predictive movement time models by systematically varying target distance (20–50 cm), target size (2.5–5 cm), and spatial configuration (0∘, 45∘, 90∘, 135∘). The second simulates an applied warehouse-inspired task involving tool sorting and structured placement actions to evaluate the generalizability of the derived models in more ecologically valid VR interactions. Thirty-two participants completed all tasks using the Meta Quest 3 headset and two interaction modalities: a handheld controller and hand tracking with gesture recognition. Results show that Fitts’ law remains a strong predictor of movement time for 3D pointing in VR, with high linear fits for both the controller (R2=0.9615) and hand tracking (R2=0.9668). However, models derived from standardized pointing tasks showed limited transferability to applied object-manipulation scenarios, producing prediction errors of approximately 27–35% and systematically underestimating movement times. Additionally, both objective metrics and subjective evaluations indicated that controller-based interaction outperformed hand tracking in efficiency, accuracy, perceived workload, and usability. These findings highlight both the robustness and limitations of Fitts-based performance modeling in realistic VR interaction contexts.