Redefining Difficult-to-Treat Systemic Lupus Erythematosus: Biomarkers of Molecular Refractoriness Beyond Clinical Failure

Difficult-to-treat systemic lupus erythematosus (D2T-SLE) remains a major unmet challenge in contemporary lupus care, yet it continues to be defined predominantly by clinical non-response rather than underlying biology. Current biomarkers largely quantify inflammatory burden, immune complex activity, or organ damage and do not reliably capture persistent activation of pathogenic pathways under therapy. Emerging multi-omics, single-cell, and longitudinal studies suggest that, in a subset of patients, apparent treatment failure may reflect incomplete attenuation of dominant immune circuits rather than uniformly elevated inflammation. We propose molecular refractoriness in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) as sustained, pathway-level immune activity despite apparently adequate, mechanism-directed therapy. We outline the major immune programs implicated in this process—including interferon-enriched, B-cell/plasmablast-associated, neutrophil extracellular trap (NET)-related, cytotoxic T-cell, and cytokine-associated states—and discuss their relevance for biomarker development and precision trial design. Importantly, we emphasize that interferon gene signatures (IGS) should be interpreted as context-dependent and non-specific markers of interferon responsiveness, reflecting combined activity of type I, II, and III interferons, and functioning primarily as predictive rather than mechanistic biomarkers. We further highlight critical limitations of a purely endotype-based model, including the need to distinguish true molecular refractoriness from damage-dominant and pseudo-refractory states, as well as the emerging role of immune-reset strategies such as cluster of differentiation 19 (CD19)-directed chimeric antigen receptor T-cell (CAR-T) therapy, which may overcome refractoriness independently of specific pathway dominance. These observations suggest that difficult-to-treat SLE encompasses biologically heterogeneous states that may not be fully captured by pathway-resolved stratification alone. Reframing D2T-SLE as a biologically heterogeneous state of incomplete immune attenuation may help bridge the gap between clinical treatment failure and mechanism-informed precision medicine in systemic lupus erythematosus.