Calculating the space-charge-limited current density for nonplanar geometries by simulating the charge-free electric field

Calculating the space-charge-limited-current density (SCLCD) for a complicated diode geometry often requires computationally expensive particle-in-cell (PIC) codes. This paper addresses this issue by using the charge-free electric field E0 calculated using COMSOL Multiphysics to determine local and global SCLCD. The SCLCD obtained by using the surface average of E02 on the cathode recovers theoretical results for one-dimensional (1D) planar, cylindrical, and tip-to-tip geometries in appropriate limits. We next compared tip-to-tip calculations with the SCLCD obtained using the PIC code Empire. The SCLCD calculated using COMSOL agreed well with Empire for flatter 1D tip-to-tip geometries and diverged with increasing sharpness. Physically, Empire predicts lower SCLCD than COMSOL because the electrons spread due to concentrated space-charge at the tip, whereas theory assumes that the electrons follow the charge-free electric field lines. We further assess the behavior of the SCLCD for tips protruding from the centers of flat, circular plates of various areas. Larger plate areas with constant tip size recover the 1D planar SCLCD globally and 1D tip-to-tip SCLCD locally, while reducing the difference between Empire and COMSOL calculations since larger plates capture more of the emitted electrons, reducing SCLCD suppression due to beam spreading. These results show that charge-free electric field simulations can be used to determine the SCLCD without needing to simulate particle dynamics in PIC.