Uni/bifractality of velocity circulation in wall-parallel concentric shells of turbulent pipe flow

Turbulent pipe flow is of substantial importance in practical applications, and it remains challenging to depict the characteristic complex multiscale dynamics by a unified theoretical framework, hindered by its inherent intermittency. Inspired by a recent study of velocity circulation in turbulent channel flows from Duan, Chen & Sreenivasan (2025 J. Fluid Mech. , vol. 1009, p. R4), in this study, we investigate the statistical characteristics of velocity circulation (or equally the area integral of wall-normal vorticity) over rectangular loops in concentric cylindrical shells, parallel to the pipe wall. The statistics are implemented using direct numerical simulation data at friction Reynolds numbers of $ \textit{Re}_\tau =1057$ and $2000$ . Close to the pipe wall, the circulation in the inertial range resides on space-filling unifractal sets, with the Hölder exponent smaller than Kolmogorov’s $4/3$ . Away from the pipe wall, the circulation displays bifractal characteristics and the Hölder exponents for high moment orders are very close to those reported in channel flows and homogeneous isotropic turbulence. The circulation statistics are only dependent on the area enclosed by the loops, and are invariant to the loop aspect ratio, once both edge lengths of the loops are in the inertial range.