Physical Restraints and Seclusion in Psychiatric Settings in the Eastern Mediterranean Region: A Systematic Review of the Perspectives of Nurses and Individuals with Mental Illness

Background/Objectives: Physical restraints and seclusion remain ethically contested interventions in psychiatric care, raising significant concerns regarding patient safety, dignity, and therapeutic impact. Despite growing international momentum towards restraint-reduction strategies, their use persists across the Eastern Mediterranean Region (EMR), an area that has been the subject of limited systematic attention. This review synthesises evidence on the knowledge, attitudes, and experiences of nurses and individuals with mental illness regarding these practices in EMR psychiatric settings. Methods: Following PRISMA 2020 guidelines (PROSPERO: CRD42023383751), we systematically searched nine electronic databases for studies published up to June 2023, supplemented by backward and forward citation searching. Multiple reviewers independently screened records against predefined eligibility criteria, with disagreements resolved through consensus. Methodological quality was assessed using Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) Critical Appraisal tools, and reporting quality was evaluated using an adapted CROSS checklist; these two appraisal dimensions were conducted and reported independently. Findings were integrated through narrative synthesis. Results: From 4634 identified records, 19 studies conducted across 11 EMR countries met the inclusion criteria. Nursing knowledge deficits were identified across multiple settings, and attitudes towards restraint practices were predominantly negative. Individuals with mental illness consistently described restraint as humiliating, punitive, and physically distressing. Recurrent challenges identified across studies included inadequate staff training, chronic understaffing, and limited access to restraint-reduction alternatives. Conclusions: Substantial gaps in nursing knowledge and training persist across the EMR. The findings of this review, while derived predominantly from cross-sectional studies with convenience samples, suggest that evidence-based education programmes, standardised restraint-reduction policies, and patient-centred care frameworks warrant prioritisation to safeguard the rights, safety, and dignity of individuals with mental illness in this region. Longitudinal and experimental research is needed to confirm these directions and establish their effectiveness within EMR contexts.