From Prompts to High-Fidelity Prototypes: A Usability Evaluation of Generative AI-Driven Prototyping Tools for Smart Mobile App Design

The integration of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GAI) into software design tools has transformed the early stages of mobile application development, particularly prototype creation from natural-language prompts. This study evaluates the usability and effectiveness of GAI-assisted prototyping tools for generating high-fidelity mobile application prototypes. A controlled laboratory usability study was conducted in which undergraduate Information Technology Engineering students used and evaluated four widely adopted prototyping platforms: Figma, Uizard, Visily, and Stitch. Participants employed these tools to recreate mobile interfaces corresponding to the interaction model of the Duolingo application. The System Usability Scale (SUS) was used to assess perceived usability and effectiveness from the users’ perspective. The results indicate that all evaluated tools enabled rapid prototype generation; however, significant differences emerged in usability, structural fidelity, and perceived control. Figma and Stitch achieved the highest usability scores and demonstrated greater alignment with the reference prototype (82.86 and 80.36, respectively). Visily achieved a favorable usability score (78.57), while Uizard obtained a moderate score (67.14). Although Uizard and Visily exhibited strong automation capabilities and faster initial generation, their outputs required additional manual refinement to achieve higher fidelity and customization. Participant feedback emphasized the importance of output quality, responsiveness, and foundational design knowledge in achieving satisfactory results. Overall, the findings suggest that current GAI-based prototyping tools are effective and valuable in real-world software development contexts. However, their effectiveness appears closely related to the degree of user control, responsiveness, and the ability to iteratively refine AI-generated interface components.