Dichotomy in Long-lived Radio Emission from Tidal Disruption Events AT 2020zso and AT 2021sdu: Multicomponent Outflows versus Host Contamination

Abstract We present a detailed radio study of the tidal disruption events (TDEs) AT 2020zso and AT 2021sdu. Both exhibit transient radio emission beginning shortly after optical discovery and persisting for several years. For AT 2020zso, we identify two distinct radio flares. The first is detected in the radio ∼22 days after the optical peak, reaching a maximum of ∼1 yr post-discovery before fading. The second flare appears ∼800 days after discovery and results in the brief presence of two distinct components in the radio spectra, providing strong evidence for physically separate outflows. Both flares are consistent with nonrelativistic outflows, with velocities of v ≈ 0.1–0.2 c and energies of E ∼ 10 49 erg, propagating through a Bondi-like circumnuclear medium. Our analysis supports a scenario in which the first outflow is accretion driven, launched while the TDE disk is accreting at a relatively high Eddington fraction, whereas the second outflow is associated with a transition to an advection-dominated accretion flow. In contrast, the radio emission from AT 2021sdu is best explained by a slower ( v ≈ 0.03 c ), less energetic outflow ( E ∼ 10 48 erg), combined with diffuse, nonvariable host emission that becomes dominant ∼500 days after discovery. Assuming free expansion, we infer an outflow launch date preceding the optical discovery date. This suggests that the outflow may originate from either the unbound stellar debris ejected during disruption or, alternatively, from a decelerating outflow. Our findings demonstrate the diversity of outflow properties in TDEs and highlight the observational challenges of interpreting late-time radio variability in the presence of host galaxy contamination.