Beyond the Magnetic Field: Rethinking the Theology-Religious Studies Relationship in the Netherlands

In this article, I reflect on the current status of the academic study of religion in the Netherlands, in particular on the relationship between theology and religious studies. I present the findings of 18 interviews with theologians and religious studies scholars of the Radboud University Nijmegen, the University of Groningen and the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, exploring how the relationship between theology and religious studies is perceived at these institutions. The image that surfaces is that of a magnetic field with opposing poles, reflecting a persistent dichotomy in how theology and religious studies are understood. However, a closer examination reveals a more nuanced and heterogeneous reality. To capture this complexity, I introduce the perspective-attitude matrix, an interpretative tool designed to illuminate the relational and contextual aspects of the discussion. Adopting such a context-sensitive approach to the debate on theology and religious studies can contribute to a more integrated and fruitful future for the academic study of religion.