Spider mite genotypes with higher growth rate suffer more from competition but exert stronger reproductive interference

Within-species individual variation has been gaining increased attention in ecological studies of species interactions. Yet, these studies rarely consider genetic variation and potential genetic correlations among traits. Moreover, traits beyond those associated with trophic interactions are mostly overlooked. Filling these gaps is important to fully understand the relevance of trait variation in both the ecology and evolution of species interactions. We addressed this using inbred lines of Tetranychus cinnabarinus, a spider mite species that often engages in antagonistic interactions with its congeneric T. urticae. Specifically, we measured (a) the intrinsic growth rate and the sex ratio in the absence of food competition and reproductive interference; (b) food competition against a density gradient of conspecific or heterospecific competitors in the absence of reproductive interference; (c) reproductive interference in the absence of food competition; and (d) the body size of adult females and males. We found significant genetic variance (i.e. broad-sense heritability) among lines for all variables except for the effect of T. cinnabarinus on its heterospecific competitor via food competition. Moreover, we showed that lines with higher intrinsic growth were more sensitive to intra- and interspecific competition for food but exerted stronger reproductive interference on heterospecifics. In addition, the higher the proportion of sons produced by a line, the more resilient it was to reproductive interference but also the lower its growth rate. No genetic correlations were found between any variable and body size. Our results indicate that considering genetic correlations among traits involved in both trophic and sexual interactions is key to understanding the role of individual variation in species interactions and their evolution.