Biomechanical comparison of anatomically precontoured patellar plate, anterior tension wiring through cannulated screws, and double-sided plating in patellar fractures using a synthetic bone model

Background: Patellar fractures are common injuries that require stable fixation to achieve optimal healing and restoration of knee function. This study aimed to analyze the mechanical properties of an anatomically precontoured patellar plate and to compare its maximum tensile load-bearing capacity with that of anterior tension wiring through cannulated screws and double-sided plating for the fixation of patellar fractures.Methods: Artificial Sawbones with a standardized transverse fracture line were used to simulate patellar fractures. Each sawbone was attached to polyester bands, and this fracture model was applied consistently across all test samples. To evaluate mechanical properties of the anatomically precontoured patellar plate (model code 25-ANPA-209) made of ASTM F67 titanium, static tensile strength testing and dynamic tensile strength testing were performed, with seven samples prepared for each test. For comparison of maximum tensile load capacity among the anatomically precontoured patellar plate, anterior tension wiring through cannulated screws, and double-sided plating, five samples were prepared for each fixation group. All specimens were tested using a tension/compression testing machine.Results: In the static tensile strength test, all seven samples exhibited a maximum tensile load capacity above 844 N without any fractures or failure points. The dynamic tensile strength test showed that all seven samples completed 10,000 cycles without deformation or damage to the anatomically precontoured patellar plate. When comparing maximum tensile load capacity, the anatomically precontoured patellar plate exhibited a significantly higher maximum tensile load-bearing capacity than anterior tension wiring through cannulated screws and double-sided plating.Conclusions: The anatomically precontoured patellar plate demonstrated satisfactory mechanical performance, successfully meeting the criteria of both static and dynamic tensile strength testing, and showed superior maximum tensile load-bearing capacity compared with the other fixation methods evaluated. These findings suggest that the anatomically precontoured patellar plate may represent a reliable fixation option for the management of patellar fractures.Level of evidence: V.