Reproducibility Archive (v4): Bridging Energy Optimization and Distributed Information Systems — Five-Layer Taxonomy and Research Agenda

{"Version":[0],"4":[1],"of":[2,22,35,61,113,124,264,306,312,344,354],"the":[3,19,23,29,32,36,59,89,91,107,115,125,140,164,196,203,211,221,256,261,301,324,339,366,377,398,407,415,439,443,448],"reproducibility":[4],"archive.":[5],"THIS":[6],"VERSION":[7],"ISSUES":[8],"A":[9,303],"CORRECTION,":[10],"and":[11,38,45,55,84,224,272,290,319,330,369,376,387,432,467],"its":[12,39,427],"scope":[13],"is":[14,78,145,215,249,326],"deliberately":[15],"narrow:":[16],"it":[17,144,168,218,421,437],"carries":[18],"supporting":[20],"materials":[21],"structured":[24],"literature":[25,126],"review":[26,30],"only":[27],"-":[28],"article,":[31],"corresponding":[33],"chapter":[34],"dissertation":[37],"introduction.":[40],"It":[41,77],"contains":[42,66],"no":[43,46,184,242,273],"code":[44,431],"datasets.":[47],"The":[48,245,362,392],"file":[49,90,248],"review_article/core_85_study_coding.csv":[50],"deposited":[51],"in":[52,80,173,187,192,195,199,202,220,382,397,406],"version":[53,383,412,424,456,463],"2,":[54],"described":[56,198],"there":[57],"as":[58,111,169,328],"coding":[60,97,247],"an":[62],"85-study":[63],"core":[64],"corpus,":[65],"29":[67],"rows":[68,143,175],"(C57-C85)":[69],"that":[70,87,118,155,417,452,470],"do":[71],"not":[72,389],"correspond":[73],"to":[74,100,176,206,300,455,460],"real":[75],"publications.":[76],"withdrawn":[79,181,234,246],"full.":[81],"Those":[82],"rows,":[83,341],"fifteen":[85],"others":[86],"entered":[88],"same":[92],"way,":[93],"carried":[94],"all":[95,461],"four":[96],"flags":[98],"set":[99],"\\"No\\",":[101],"so":[102,323],"every":[103,267],"share":[104,161],"computed":[105,162],"over":[106,139,163,282,338],"85":[108],"counted":[109],"them":[110,188],"evidence":[112],"absence:":[114],"published":[116,222],"finding":[117],"fewer":[119],"than":[120,435,459],"ten":[121],"per":[122],"cent":[123],"explicitly":[127],"models":[128],"data":[129,345,433],"locality":[130,346],"or":[131,157,201,347],"sovereignty":[132,348],"was":[133,310],"7/85":[134],"=":[135,147],"8.2":[136],"%,":[137],"where":[138],"41":[141],"sound":[142],"7/41":[146],"17.1":[148],"%.":[149],"Anyone":[150],"who":[151],"has":[152],"relied":[153],"on":[154,158],"figure,":[156],"any":[159,190],"other":[160],"85,":[165],"should":[166],"treat":[167],"withdrawn.":[170],"Author":[171],"attributions":[172],"those":[174,404],"real,":[177],"identifiable":[178],"researchers":[179],"are":[180,381,388,401],"without":[182],"reservation;":[183],"person":[185],"named":[186],"had":[189],"involvement":[191],"this":[193],"deposit,":[194],"work":[197],"it,":[200,227],"material":[204],"attributed":[205],"them.":[207,419],"CORRECTION":[208],"NOTICE.md,":[209],"inside":[210],"archive,":[212],"states":[213],"what":[214,217,225],"withdrawn,":[216],"changes":[219],"statistics":[223],"replaces":[226],"together":[228],"with":[229,372],"three":[230],"further":[231],"version-2":[232],"files":[233],"because":[235],"they":[236],"assert":[237],"retrieval":[238],"figures":[239,395],"for":[240,430,447],"which":[241,313],"log":[243],"exists.":[244],"replaced":[250],"by":[251,260,288,403,426],"\\"core":[252],"162":[253,257,317,340],"study":[254],"coding.csv\\":":[255],"studies":[258,297],"included":[259,318],"full-text":[262],"screen":[263],"September":[265],"2026,":[266],"row":[268],"carrying":[269],"a":[270,410],"DOI":[271,385,429,445],"placeholder":[274],"rows.":[275],"Two":[276],"identification":[277],"routes:":[278],"1,500":[279],"records":[280,333],"examined":[281],"five":[283],"Crossref":[284],"strings":[285],"(1,186":[286],"unique":[287],"DOI),":[289],"2,416":[291],"citation":[292],"hits":[293],"from":[294],"34":[295],"seed":[296],"(2,109":[298],"new":[299],"pool).":[302],"stratified":[304],"sample":[305],"283":[307],"full":[308],"texts":[309],"assessed,":[311],"116":[314],"were":[315,334],"excluded,":[316],"5":[320],"remain":[321],"undecided,":[322],"flow":[325],"reported":[327,405],"provisional":[329],"657":[331],"eligible":[332],"never":[335],"assessed.":[336],"Recomputed":[337],"explicit":[342],"modelling":[343],"stands":[349],"at":[350],"6.2":[351],"%":[352],"(10":[353],"162).":[355],"WHERE":[356],"THE":[357],"CODE":[358],"AND":[359],"DATA":[360],"ARE.":[361],"executable":[363],"framework":[364],"code,":[365],"public":[367],"CAISO":[368],"EIA":[370],"datasets":[371],"their":[373],"acquisition":[374],"scripts,":[375],"experimental":[378,394],"result":[379],"tables":[380],"3,":[384],"10.5281/zenodo.20773722,":[386],"duplicated":[390],"here.":[391],"headline":[393],"printed":[396],"version-3":[399],"description":[400],"superseded":[402],"associated":[408],"dissertation;":[409],"subsequent":[411],"will":[413],"carry":[414],"configuration":[416],"produces":[418],"Until":[420],"does,":[422],"cite":[423],"3":[425],"own":[428,465],"rather":[434,458],"reaching":[436],"through":[438],"concept":[440,444],"DOI.":[441],"Cite":[442],"10.5281/zenodo.19296694":[446],"latest":[449],"version.":[450],"Note":[451],"10.5281/zenodo.19296695":[453],"resolves":[454],"1":[457],"versions;":[462],"2's":[464],"README":[466],"manifest":[468],"made":[469],"error.":[471]}

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Published
2026-09-14
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19296694
Primary Topic
Integrated Energy Systems Optimization
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
preprint

Reproducibility Archive (v4): Bridging Energy Optimization and Distributed Information Systems — Five-Layer Taxonomy and Research Agenda

Shwan Mohammed Abdulwahhab Aljaf
Integrated Energy Systems Optimization
preprint

Reproducibility Archive (v4): Bridging Energy Optimization and Distributed Information Systems — Five-Layer Taxonomy and Research Agenda

Shwan Mohammed Abdulwahhab Aljaf
preprint en

Abstract

Version 4 of the reproducibility archive. THIS VERSION ISSUES A CORRECTION, and its scope is deliberately narrow: it carries the supporting materials of the structured literature review only - the review article, the corresponding chapter of the dissertation and its introduction. It contains no code and no datasets. The file review_article/core_85_study_coding.csv deposited in version 2, and described there as the coding of an 85-study core corpus, contains 29 rows (C57-C85) that do not correspond to real publications. It is withdrawn in full. Those rows, and fifteen others that entered the file the same way, carried all four coding flags set to "No", so every share computed over the 85 counted them as evidence of absence: the published finding that fewer than ten per cent of the literature explicitly models data locality or sovereignty was 7/85 = 8.2 %, where over the 41 sound rows it is 7/41 = 17.1 %. Anyone who has relied on that figure, or on any other share computed over the 85, should treat it as withdrawn. Author attributions in those rows to real, identifiable researchers are withdrawn without reservation; no person named in them had any involvement in this deposit, in the work described in it, or in the material attributed to them. CORRECTION NOTICE.md, inside the archive, states what is withdrawn, what it changes in the published statistics and what replaces it, together with three further version-2 files withdrawn because they assert retrieval figures for which no log exists. The withdrawn coding file is replaced by "core 162 study coding.csv": the 162 studies included by the full-text screen of September 2026, every row carrying a DOI and no placeholder rows. Two identification routes: 1,500 records examined over five Crossref strings (1,186 unique by DOI), and 2,416 citation hits from 34 seed studies (2,109 new to the pool). A stratified sample of 283 full texts was assessed, of which 116 were excluded, 162 included and 5 remain undecided, so the flow is reported as provisional and 657 eligible records were never assessed. Recomputed over the 162 rows, explicit modelling of data locality or sovereignty stands at 6.2 % (10 of 162). WHERE THE CODE AND DATA ARE. The executable framework code, the public CAISO and EIA datasets with their acquisition scripts, and the experimental result tables are in version 3, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20773722, and are not duplicated here. The headline experimental figures printed in the version-3 description are superseded by those reported in the associated dissertation; a subsequent version will carry the configuration that produces them. Until it does, cite version 3 by its own DOI for code and data rather than reaching it through the concept DOI. Cite the concept DOI 10.5281/zenodo.19296694 for the latest version. Note that 10.5281/zenodo.19296695 resolves to version 1 rather than to all versions; version 2's own README and manifest made that error.

Southern Federal University (RU)
Integrated Energy Systems Optimization
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.