The cost of “what might have been”: false memories for counterfactual actions

{"Deciding":[0],"what":[1,8],"to":[2,89,105,125,135,152,164],"do":[3],"should":[4],"typically":[5],"involve":[6],"considering":[7],"could":[9],"have":[10,145],"been":[11],"done,":[12],"but":[13,101,143],"in":[14,29,44,62,167],"fact":[15],"was":[16],"not":[17,201,221],"done.":[18],"We":[19],"tested":[20],"whether":[21],"such":[22],"unchosen":[23,77,100,190],"alternative":[24,50,165],"action":[25,130,185,212],"paths":[26,220],"leave":[27],"traces":[28,218],"memory.":[30],"Across":[31],"two":[32,49],"behavioural":[33],"experiments,":[34],"participants":[35],"solved":[36],"a":[37,59,116,146,209],"modified":[38],"Tower":[39],"of":[40,67,148,189,219],"London":[41],"(ToL)":[42],"task":[43],"which":[45,63],"each":[46],"problem":[47],"afforded":[48],"and":[51,115,195],"equivalent":[52],"optimal":[53],"solution":[54],"paths.":[55],"They":[56],"then":[57],"undertook":[58],"recognition":[60],"test":[61],"they":[64,93],"viewed":[65],"configurations":[66,97,123],"the":[68,73,76,99,182],"ToL":[69],"drawn":[70],"either":[71],"from":[72,80,98,137],"chosen":[74],"path,":[75,78,103],"or":[79],"new,":[81],"unviewed":[82],"configurations.":[83,107,128],"Participants":[84],"were":[85,162],"consistently":[86],"more":[87,117,207],"likely":[88],"judge":[90],"(falsely)":[91],"that":[92,139,150,184,192],"had":[94],"previously":[95],"seen":[96],"plausible":[102],"compared":[104,124],"novel":[106,127,160],"Signal":[108],"detection":[109],"analyses":[110],"further":[111],"showed":[112],"reduced":[113],"discriminability":[114],"liberal":[118],"decision":[119],"criterion":[120],"for":[121],"alternative-path":[122],"control":[126],"Unchosen":[129],"alternatives":[131,191],"may":[132,144],"be":[133],"difficult":[134],"distinguish":[136],"actions":[138],"are":[140,179],"actually":[141],"executed,":[142],"feeling":[147],"familiarity":[149],"leads":[151],"an":[153],"\\"old\\"":[154],"response.":[155],"This":[156],"effect":[157],"replicated":[158],"when":[159],"items":[161,166],"matched":[163],"visual":[168],"similarity,":[169],"ruling":[170],"out":[171],"explanations":[172],"based":[173],"on":[174],"perceptual":[175],"confusability.":[176],"The":[177],"results":[178],"consistent":[180],"with":[181],"idea":[183],"planning":[186],"generates":[187],"representations":[188],"can":[193],"persist":[194],"bias":[196],"later":[197],"memory,":[198],"even":[199],"if":[200],"executed.":[202],"Planning":[203],"therefore":[204],"leaves":[205,216],"behind":[206],"than":[208],"route":[210],"toward":[211],"goals:":[213],"it":[214],"also":[215],"mnemonic":[217],"taken.":[222]}

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Cognition
Published
2026-09-04
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.2026.106701
Primary Topic
Action Observation and Synchronization
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
article

The cost of “what might have been”: false memories for counterfactual actions

Silvia Seghezzi, Maia Juliet Armstrong, Patrick Haggard
Cognition
Action Observation and Synchronization
article

The cost of “what might have been”: false memories for counterfactual actions

Silvia Seghezzi, Maia Juliet Armstrong, Patrick Haggard
article en

Abstract

Deciding what to do should typically involve considering what could have been done, but in fact was not done. We tested whether such unchosen alternative action paths leave traces in memory. Across two behavioural experiments, participants solved a modified Tower of London (ToL) task in which each problem afforded two alternative and equivalent optimal solution paths. They then undertook a recognition test in which they viewed configurations of the ToL drawn either from the chosen path, the unchosen path, or from new, unviewed configurations. Participants were consistently more likely to judge (falsely) that they had previously seen configurations from the unchosen but plausible path, compared to novel configurations. Signal detection analyses further showed reduced discriminability and a more liberal decision criterion for alternative-path configurations compared to control novel configurations. Unchosen action alternatives may be difficult to distinguish from actions that are actually executed, but may have a feeling of familiarity that leads to an "old" response. This effect replicated when novel items were matched to alternative items in visual similarity, ruling out explanations based on perceptual confusability. The results are consistent with the idea that action planning generates representations of unchosen alternatives that can persist and bias later memory, even if not executed. Planning therefore leaves behind more than a route toward action goals: it also leaves mnemonic traces of paths not taken.

CognitionVol. 278
University College London (GB), Birkbeck, University of London (GB)
Experimental Psychology Society
Reduced inequalities
Openalex Percentile: Top 75%
Action Observation and Synchronization
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.