Beyond the laboratory: rank concordance of rapid methodologies for soil health assessment

Soil health assessment increasingly relies on biological indicators because of their sensitivity and direct links to ecosystem functioning. However, conventional laboratory methods are time-consuming, require specialized infrastructure, and are often incompatible with rapid decision-making in applied contexts. Several rapid or field-deployable tools have recently been developed to address this limitation, but their ability to reproduce the relative ordering of samples obtained with laboratory methods remains insufficiently evaluated. Here, we compared four rapid approaches with their corresponding laboratory methods in a long-term grassland experiment: aggregate stability (SLAKES), soil respiration (portable CO 2 analyzer), microbial biomass carbon and fungal-to-bacterial ratio (microBIOMETER ® ), and enzyme activities (Soil Enzymatic Activity Reader, SEAR). Rank concordance between methods was assessed using Spearman correlations, partial redundancy analyses and Procrustes analysis. Aggregate stability showed strong rank concordance between rapid and laboratory measurements (median ρ =0.65; range: 0.44–0.79), whereas soil respiration exhibited very weak rank concordance, likely reflecting that in situ and laboratory approaches capture different aspects of respiratory activity. Microbial biomass carbon displayed strong rank concordance between methods (median ρ =0.68; range: 0.54–0.76), while fungal-to-bacterial ratios did not. Enzyme activities measured with SEAR generally reproduced the patterns observed with laboratory assays. Multivariate analyses indicated that, overall, rapid methods captured patterns of variation associated with sampling depth that were similar to those revealed by laboratory protocols. These findings indicate that selected rapid tools can reproduce relative patterns among samples and treatments and may therefore provide useful information when laboratory facilities are unavailable or timely soil health information is required to inform management decisions.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
SOIL
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5194/soil-12-1187-2026
Primary Topic
Soil Carbon and Nitrogen Dynamics
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Beyond the laboratory: rank concordance of rapid methodologies for soil health assessment

Lur Epelde, N. Mandaluniz, Katy Jo Stanton, Mikel Anza et al.
2 links
SOIL
Soil Carbon and Nitrogen Dynamics
article

Beyond the laboratory: rank concordance of rapid methodologies for soil health assessment

Lur Epelde, N. Mandaluniz, Katy Jo Stanton, Mikel Anza, Jasmin Fetzer, Josiah B. Judson
article en

Abstract

Soil health assessment increasingly relies on biological indicators because of their sensitivity and direct links to ecosystem functioning. However, conventional laboratory methods are time-consuming, require specialized infrastructure, and are often incompatible with rapid decision-making in applied contexts. Several rapid or field-deployable tools have recently been developed to address this limitation, but their ability to reproduce the relative ordering of samples obtained with laboratory methods remains insufficiently evaluated. Here, we compared four rapid approaches with their corresponding laboratory methods in a long-term grassland experiment: aggregate stability (SLAKES), soil respiration (portable CO 2 analyzer), microbial biomass carbon and fungal-to-bacterial ratio (microBIOMETER ® ), and enzyme activities (Soil Enzymatic Activity Reader, SEAR). Rank concordance between methods was assessed using Spearman correlations, partial redundancy analyses and Procrustes analysis. Aggregate stability showed strong rank concordance between rapid and laboratory measurements (median ρ =0.65; range: 0.44–0.79), whereas soil respiration exhibited very weak rank concordance, likely reflecting that in situ and laboratory approaches capture different aspects of respiratory activity. Microbial biomass carbon displayed strong rank concordance between methods (median ρ =0.68; range: 0.54–0.76), while fungal-to-bacterial ratios did not. Enzyme activities measured with SEAR generally reproduced the patterns observed with laboratory assays. Multivariate analyses indicated that, overall, rapid methods captured patterns of variation associated with sampling depth that were similar to those revealed by laboratory protocols. These findings indicate that selected rapid tools can reproduce relative patterns among samples and treatments and may therefore provide useful information when laboratory facilities are unavailable or timely soil health information is required to inform management decisions.

SOILVol. 12(2)
Soil Association (GB), Euskadiko Parke Teknologikoa (ES), NEIKER, Basque Institute for Agricultural Research and Development (ES)
European Commission, HORIZON EUROPE Framework Programme, HORIZON EUROPE Global Challenges and European Industrial Competitiveness
Life on land, Zero hunger
Soil Carbon and Nitrogen Dynamics
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon