Performance Evaluation of NIST-Standardized Post-Quantum and Symmetric Ciphers for Mitigating Deepfakes

Deepfake technology can produce highly realistic manipulated media which pose as significant cybersecurity threats, including fraud, misinformation, and privacy violations. This research proposes a deepfake prevention approach based on symmetric and asymmetric ciphers. Post-quantum asymmetric ciphers were utilized to perform digital signature operations, which offer essential security services, including integrity, authentication, and non-repudiation. Symmetric ciphers were also employed to provide confidentiality and authentication. Unlike classical ciphers that are vulnerable to quantum attacks, this study adopts quantum-resilient ciphers to offer long-term security. The proposed approach enables entities to digitally sign media content before public release on other platforms. End users can subsequently verify the authenticity of content using the public keys of the media creators. To identify the most efficient ciphers to perform cryptography operations required for deepfake prevention, the study explores the implementation of quantum-resilient symmetric and asymmetric ciphers standardized by NIST, including Dilithium, Falcon, SPHINCS+, and Ascon-80pq. Additionally, this research provides comprehensive comparisons between the various classical and post-quantum ciphers in both categories: symmetric and asymmetric. Experimental results revealed that Dilithium-5 and Falcon-512 algorithms outperform other post-quantum ciphers, with a time delay of 2.50 and 251 ms, respectively, for digital signature operations. The Falcon-512 algorithm also demonstrates superior resource efficiency, making it a cost-effective choice for digital signature operations. With respect to symmetric ciphers, Ascon-80pq achieved the lowest time consumption, taking just 0.015 ms to perform encryption and decryption operations. Also, it is a significant option for constrained devices, since it consumes fewer resources compared to standard symmetric ciphers, such as AES. Through comprehensive evaluations and comparisons of various symmetric and asymmetric ciphers, this study serves as a blueprint to identify the most efficient ciphers to perform the cryptography operations necessary for deepfake prevention.