Building Knowledge Infrastructure for Circular Economy: Systematic Barriers to Recycled, Reusable, and Reclaimed Material Adoption in UK Construction
Recycled, reusable, and reclaimed (RRR) materials comprise less than 10% of UK construction inputs despite comprehensive ISO circular economy standards and urgent postGrenfell safety reforms mandating evidence-based material selection. This research examines why knowledge infrastructure deficits—not coordination failures or organizational resistance—prevent RRR material adoption, contributing to key research priorities on knowledge production in decision making, decision-making practices, and actionable policy research. Drawing on government-funded research through the Office for Product Safety and Standards (OPSS), we demonstrate how circular economy standards presuppose knowledge infrastructure that does not exist, creating “capability-constrained ceremonial compliance” where organizations adopt frameworks symbolically while lacking enabling infrastructure. Evidence from 474 stakeholders (242 industry professionals, of whom 222 provided complete environmental knowledge data, and 232 homeowners) reveals three systematic knowledge-policy gaps: a safety verification infrastructure gap (70.3% of homeowners demand laboratory testing versus 45.1% of suppliers currently providing it—a 25.1 percentage point gap); a coordination infrastructure deficit (50.9% experience procurement difficulties regardless of firm size or supply chain position); and an environmental knowledge gap (76.1% of industry professionals lack carbon knowledge despite 91.4% demanding government calculation tools). These gaps reflect absent information problems—knowledge infrastructure preventing environmental knowledge production and use—rather than coordination challenges. We propose capability-sequencing logic requiring government investment in verification, coordination, and environmental knowledge infrastructure before mandating RRR material compliance, reversing current policy approaches presuming enabling infrastructure exists. PostGrenfell urgency creating verification infrastructure opportunities, net-zero 2050 commitments mandating capability building, and environmental justice concerns (social housing 54.5% unlikely to adopt RRR materials) make these insights immediately actionable for construction sustainability transitions worldwide.
Authors
- Priyanka Roy (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0008-7269-7130)
- Ricky S Wong
Institutions
- University of Hertfordshire (GB)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1061/jcemd4.coeng-19091
- Primary Topic
- Sustainable Supply Chain Management
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00