From Baseline to Blended Feedback: A Within-Subjects Study of AI-Generated and Teacher-Delivered Feedback in EFL Writing
This 8-week mixed-methods study examined how English as a foreign language (EFL) learners navigate, interpret, and appropriate ChatGPT-generated and teacher-delivered feedback across sequential instructional phases, and what motivational and writing consequences this navigation produces. Using a within-subjects design, 24 intermediate university-level EFL learners completed 5 genre-based paragraph tasks across 3 feedback phases: baseline (no feedback), ChatGPT-only (GPT-4o mini), and blended (ChatGPT combined with teacher mediation). Data comprised rubric-based writing scores, phase-specific surveys, and focus-group interviews analyzed through the AI-Mediated Writing (AIM-W) framework. Qualitative findings revealed a developmental arc in feedback literacy: from prompt-bounded experimentation in Phase 2, through layered scaffolding recognition and selective agency, to ethical calibration of AI use in Phase 3. Motivational trajectories followed self-determination theory predictions: autonomy and competence dominated during ChatGPT-only interaction, while teacher mediation reintroduced relatedness, the missing motivational dimension, and unexpectedly strengthened trust in AI-generated feedback itself. Writing performance patterns showed micro-level stability across phases despite escalating genre demands, and macro-level gains under blended feedback, though these are reported cautiously given that genre complexity co-varied with feedback phase, constituting a design limitation that precludes causal attribution. The study contributes an empirically grounded account of how feedback literacy develops in multisource AI feedback settings, with specific implications for prompt-literacy instruction, feedback sequencing, and the pedagogical conditions under which AI-generated feedback can be responsibly integrated into EFL writing classrooms.
Authors
- Harun ÇİFTCİ (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1444-641X)
Institutions
- Isparta University of Applied Sciences (TR)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Language Teaching Research
- Published
- 2026-11-19
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1177/13621688261499965
- Primary Topic
- EFL/ESL Teaching and Learning
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00