Environmental Contributions to Proton Sharing in Protein Low-Barrier Hydrogen Bonds

Hydrogen bonds (H-bonds) are central to biomolecular structure and dynamics. Although H-bonds are typically characterized by well-defined proton positions, proton delocalization has been proposed to play a role in facilitating enzyme catalysis and allostery in some systems. Experimentally locating protons is difficult, hampering the study of proton mobility in H-bonds. We used neutron crystallography, atomic resolution X-ray bond length analysis, and large quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics-Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics (QM/MM-BOMD) simulations to comprehensively characterize the shared proton/deuteron in a Glu-Asp low-barrier hydrogen bond (LBHB) in the bacterial protein YajL that is a conventional H-bond in the homologous disease-associated human protein DJ-1. X-ray bond length analysis of protiated and perdeuterated DJ-1 and YajL shows no significant effect of deuteron substitution on these carboxylic acid-carboxylate H-bonds but does reveal an effect at the active site glutamic acid near a cysteine thiolate. Residues in an H-bonded network that might favor LBHB formation in YajL were interrogated by the mutation of homologous residues in DJ-1. A distal DJ-1 substitution increases proton delocalization in the Glu-Asp H-bond, demonstrating that mutations within extended H-bond networks can modulate proton transfer barriers in carboxylic acid-carboxylate H-bonds. In addition, proton mobility in the H-bond is correlated with dimer-spanning motions in the QM/MM-BOMD simulations of YajL and DJ-1. Our results show that proton delocalization can be tuned using combined bioinformatic, structural, and computational information, opening the possibility of using engineered proton delocalization as a probe of H-bonding environments and as a tool to test hypotheses about LBHB function.