Surgical outcomes in nonagenarian versus octogenarian patients: a propensity-matched analysis with implications for shared decision-making

Nonagenarian patients face substantially worse surgical outcomes than octogenarian patients, with nearly triple the 30-day mortality and high rates of functional impairment among survivors. The persistent frailty imbalance despite matching suggests inherent selection bias in surgical nonagenarians. Unlike octogenarians, for whom selective surgery may be justified, these findings support careful consideration of nonoperative management as the default approach for nonagenarians, with surgery reserved for highly select cases after comprehensive geriatric assessment and thorough shared decision-making with the patient.