Evaluating damping schemes for the discontinuum seismic analysis of masonry cross-vaults

Simulating the seismic behaviour of unreinforced masonry (URM) is challenging due to large deformations and severe damage. Capturing this highly nonlinear response requires advanced numerical modelling strategies that represent block separation, debonding, friction, and impact. Discontinuum-based modelling strategies, such as the Distinct Element Method (DEM), are well suited, as they explicitly represent bond failure and damage progression from cracking to collapse. DEM relies on the explicit time integration scheme of motion equations; hence, the choice of the damping scheme becomes critical. Typically, mass-proportional damping is used in dynamic analysis, often without complementing it with stiffness-proportional damping which requires unpractical reduction of the time steps to ensure numerical stability. Yet relying solely on mass-proportional damping can overdamp low frequencies and underdamp high frequencies. This study implements and validates an alternative damping approach, Maxwell damping, where multiple spring-dashpot elements are introduced at unit-mortar interfaces within a simplified micro-model. This work introduces an optimization algorithm to tune the Maxwell elements without heuristics, targeting near-uniform damping over a broad frequency range. Effectiveness is assessed against shake-table tests on a full-scale cross-vault URM specimen. Predicted displacements, accelerations, damage evolution, and computational efficiency is compared with mass-proportional and zero-viscous damping models. This study investigates Maxwell damping as a practical relaxation scheme for the seismic analysis of complex masonry systems using DEM, building on prior formulations in the literature and extending them to the present modelling and validation context.