Comparative Study of Supervised Deep Learning Architectures for Background Subtraction and Motion Segmentation on CDnet2014

Foreground segmentation and background subtraction are critical components in many computer vision applications, such as intelligent video surveillance, urban security systems, and obstacle detection for autonomous vehicles. Although extensively studied over the past decades, these tasks remain challenging, particularly due to rapid illumination changes, dynamic backgrounds, cast shadows, and camera movements. The emergence of supervised deep learning-based methods has significantly enhanced performance, surpassing traditional approaches on the benchmark dataset CDnet2014. In this context, this paper provides a comprehensive review of recent supervised deep learning techniques applied to background subtraction, along with an in-depth comparative analysis of state-of-the-art approaches available on the official CDnet2014 results platform. Specifically, we examine several key architecture families, including convolutional neural networks (CNN and FCN), encoder–decoder models such as FgSegNet and Motion U-Net, adversarial frameworks (GAN), Transformer-based architectures, and hybrid methods combining intermittent semantic segmentation with rapid detection algorithms such as RT-SBS-v2. Beyond summarizing existing works, this review contributes a structured cross-family comparison under a unified benchmark, a focused analysis of performance behavior across challenging CDnet2014 scenarios, and a critical discussion of the trade-offs between segmentation accuracy, robustness, and computational efficiency for practical deployment.