Severity of physical, emotional, and cognitive symptoms is associated with future persistence of acute post-traumatic headache attributed to mild traumatic brain injury

AimPost-traumatic headache (PTH) attributed to mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) frequently co-occurs with other physical, cognitive, and emotional symptoms. This study assessed associations between PTH improvement and these symptoms in individuals with acute headaches (APTH) and compared symptoms between those who had recently developed persistent PTH (PPTH) to those who had long-standing PPTH.MethodsThis study included 105 individuals with APTH (mean age = 43.4, SD = 15.8; 70 females, 35 males) and 46 individuals with PPTH (mean age = 38.2, SD = 10.9; 16 females, 30 males) with an average duration of 11.3 years from two prospective longitudinal studies. For those who had APTH, PTH improvement was assessed at three months post-enrollment using an electronic headache diary. Participants completed questionnaires evaluating physical (including headache symptoms, photosensitivity, hyperacusis, insomnia, autonomic symptoms, and disability), emotional (including depression, anxiety, pain catastrophizing, and post-traumatic stress disorder screening), and cognitive symptoms (including memory and attention). The APTH cohort completed questionnaires at baseline, follow-up #1 (three to four months from baseline), and follow-up #2 (six to seven months from baseline). Mixed Effects Models were used to analyze the temporal trend of symptoms among the APTH improved and non-improved groups.ResultsAmong the 105 individuals with APTH, 60 experienced PTH improvement and 45 did not. At baseline, compared to those who had PTH improvement, those who did not have PTH improvement had higher SCAT total scores and physical subscores, greater levels of hyperacusis, pain catastrophizing, anxiety and depression. At follow-up #1 (three to four months), these individuals continued to show more pronounced physical and emotional symptoms and worse cognitive function and insomnia. Most of these group differences persisted at follow-up #2 (six to seven months). Most symptoms showed progressive improvement over three months for individuals who had PTH improvement but not for those without PTH improvement. Furthermore, individuals with long-standing PPTH showed more severe insomnia, pain catastrophizing, and PTSD compared to those who had recently developed PPTH.ConclusionIndividuals with APTH who did not experience PTH improvement at three months had more severe physical, cognitive, and emotional symptoms at baseline compared to those who had PTH improvement. While most symptoms normalized in individuals with PTH improvement, symptoms overall persisted at three and at six months for those with PTH persistence. Individuals who had long-standing PPTH had more severe insomnia and more negative cognitive/emotional responses to pain compared to those who had recently developed PPTH.