Pb-Apatite Framework as a Generator of Novel Flat-Band CuO-Based Physics

Based upon density functional theory (DFT) calculations, we present the basic electronic structure of CuPb9(PO4)6O (Cu-doped lead apatite, aka LK-99), in two scenarios: (1) where the structure is constrained to the P3 symmetry and (2) where no symmetry is imposed. At the DFT level, the former is predicted to be metallic while the latter is found to be a charge-transfer insulator. In both cases the filling of these states is nominally d9, consistent with the standard Cu2+ valence state, and Cu with a local magnetic moment of order 0.7 μB. In the metallic case we find these states to be unusually flat (∼0.2 eV dispersion), giving a very high density of electronic states (DOS) at the Fermi level that we argue can be a host for novel electronic physics. The flatness of the bands is the likely origin of symmetry-lowering gapping possibilities that would remove the spectral weight from EF. Motivated by some initial experimental observations of metallic or semiconducting behavior, we propose that disorder (likely structural) is responsible for closing the gap. Here, we consider a variety of possibilities that could possibly close the charge-transfer gap but limit consideration to kinds of disorder that preserve electron count. Of the possible kinds we considered (spin disorder, O populating vacancy sites, and Cu on less energetically favorable Pb sites), the local Cu moment, and consequently the charge-transfer gap, remains robust. We conclude that disorder responsible for metallic behavior entails some kind of doping where the electron count changes. Further, we claim that the emergence of the flat bands should be due to weak wave function overlap between the orbitals on Cu and O sites, owing to the directional character of the constituent orbitals. Therefore, finding an appropriate host structure for minimizing hybridization between Cu and O while allowing them to still weakly interact should be a promising route for generating flat bands at EF which can lead to interesting electronic phenomena, regardless of whether LK-99 is a superconductor.