Machine Learning as a Lens on NWP ICON Configurations Validation over Southern Italy in Winter 2022–2023—Part I: Empirical Orthogonal Functions

Validation of ICON model configurations optimized over a limited domain is essential before accepting new semi-empirical parameters that influence the behavior of subgrid-scale schemes. Because such parameters can modify the dynamics of a numerical weather prediction (NWP) model in highly nonlinear ways, we analyze one season of forecasts (December 2022, January and February 2023) generated with the NWP ICON-LAM through the lens of machine learning–based diagnostics as a complement to traditional evaluation metrics. The goal is to extract physically interpretable information on the model behavior induced by the optimized parameters. This work represents the first part of a wider study exploring machine learning tools for model validation, focusing on two specific approaches: Empirical Orthogonal Functions (EOFs), which are widely used in meteorology and climate science, and autoencoders, which are increasingly adopted for their nonlinear feature extraction capability. In this first part, EOF analysis is used as the primary tool to decompose weather fields from observed reanalysis and forecast datasets. Hourly 2-m temperature forecasts for winter 2022–2023 from multiple regional ICON configurations are compared against downscaled ERA5 data and in situ observations from ground station. EOF analyses revealed that the optimized configurations demonstrate a high skill in predicting surface temperature. From the signal error decomposition, the fourth EOF mode is effective particularly during night-time hours, and contributes to enhancing the performance of ICON. Analyses based on autoencoders will be presented in a companion paper (Part II).