PROMETHEE-Based Ranking of EU Countries Across Key Agricultural and Environmental Indicators

This study evaluates the agri-environmental performance of the EU-27 Member States using the PROMETHEE multiple-criteria decision analysis method, based on three Eurostat indicators linked to the sustainability pillars: Harmonized Risk Indicator 1 (HRI1, social pillar), pesticide sales intensity (kg/ha UAA, environmental pillar), and environmental protection investments (% GDP, economic pillar). The analysis uses the most recent available Eurostat data (primarily from 2023) and examines three weighting scenarios: (i) equal weights, (ii) higher emphasis on the economic pillar, and (iii) higher emphasis on the environmental and social pillars. Across all scenarios, Slovenia ranked first (net flow, φ = 0.4173 to 0.4734), followed by Czechia (φ = 0.2796 to 0.3260) and France (φ = 0.1886 to 0.2240), while Malta (φ = −0.3356 to −0.3691), Cyprus (φ = −0.2916 to −0.3027), and Estonia (φ = −0.2641 to −0.2903) consistently occupied the lowest positions. The stability of rankings across alternative weighting schemes indicates robust performance patterns, with minimal shifts for most Member States. Overall, the results highlight persistent cross-country differences in agri-environmental performance despite common EU regulatory frameworks, underlining the relevance of national implementation capacity and investment strategies. The proposed PROMETHEE-based ranking provides a transparent and policy-aligned benchmarking tool that can support monitoring and prioritization of interventions related to pesticide risk reduction and environmental investment across EU Member States.