Apatite Geochemical Signatures of REE Ore-Forming Processes in Carbonatite System: A Case Study of the Weishan REE Deposit, Luxi Terrane

The Weishan rare earth element (REE) deposit, located in western Shandong, North China Block, is a typical carbonatite REE deposit and constitutes the third largest light REE resource in China. Its mineralization is closely related to the multi-stage evolution of a carbonatite magma–hydrothermal system. However, the mechanisms governing REE enrichment, migration, and precipitation remain insufficiently constrained from a mineralogical perspective, which hampers the understanding of the ore-forming processes and the establishment of predictive exploration models. Apatite is a pervasively developed REE phase in the Weishan deposit which occurs in multiple generations, and thus represents an ideal recorder of the magmatic–hydrothermal evolution. In this study, different generations of apatite hosted in carbonatite orebodies from the Weishan deposit were investigated using cathodoluminescence (CL), electron probe microanalysis (EPMA), and in situ LA-ICP-MS trace element analysis. Three types of apatite were identified. In paragenetic sequence, Ap-1 occurs as polycrystalline aggregates coexisting with calcite, is enriched in Na, Sr, and LREEs, and shows high (La/Yb)N ratios, suggesting crystallization from an evolved carbonatite magma. Ap-2 and Ap-3 display typical replacement textures: both contain abundant dissolution pits and dissolution channels within the grains, which are filled by secondary minerals such as monazite and ancylite, and thus exhibit characteristic features of fluid-mediated dissolution–reprecipitation during the hydrothermal stage. Ap-2 is commonly associated with barite and strontianite, whereas Ap-3 is associated with pyrite and monazite and is characterized by relatively sharp grain boundaries with adjacent minerals. From Ap-1 to Ap-3, total REE contents decrease systematically, whereas Na, Sr, and P contents increase. All three apatite types lack Eu anomalies but display positive Ce anomalies. Discrimination diagrams involving LREE-Sr/Y and log(Ce)-log(Eu/Y) indicate that apatite in the Weishan REE deposit formed during the magmatic to hydrothermal evolution of a carbonatite, and that the dissolution of early magmatic apatite, followed by element remobilization and mineral reprecipitation, effectively records the progressive evolution of the ore-forming fluid.