Process diagnostics of snowmelt runoff in global hydrological and land surface models – Part 2: Are more complex models better?

The added value of increased process complexity has long been a central yet unresolved question in hydrological modeling, particularly for snowmelt runoff (SMR), where multiple physical processes interact in complex ways. In this study, we develop a Tree-Based Model Complexity Scoring (TBMCS) method to quantify the complexity of snow-related processes across 13 global hydrological and land surface models. We then systematically revisit the important linkage between model complexity and model performance in three distinct SMR characteristics, i.e., total runoff ( Q sum ), peak flow ( Q max ), and centroid timing (CTQ) of runoff in the snowmelt period. Further, we assess how the basin complexity (as delineated by 1455 snow-dominated basins), forcing difference and calibration status can modulate this linkage. Results show that (1) models differ substantially in their physical process representations, with the largest divergence in melting process treatments, followed by sublimation, interception and rainfall-snowfall partitioning processes. (2) Model performance for Q sum and Q max shows only weak associations with model complexity. Interestingly, we find a positive correlation between snow-process complexity and model performance for CTQ ( r =0.32). This relationship remains positive under high basin complexity ( r =0.35) and becomes statistically significant within the subgroup of models driven by GSWP3–W5E5 ( r =0.81, P <0.05). These findings suggest that greater snow-process complexity may be associated with improved simulation of runoff timing. Finally, we also find that (3) model performance depends more on systematic and balanced representations of key processes than on model complexity alone. These findings suggest that greater snow-process complexity may be associated with improved simulation of runoff timing but not runoff magnitude. By providing a quantitative and process-traceable framework for assessing model complexity, this study helps identify which process representations are most relevant for improving SMR simulations under complex environmental conditions.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Hydrology and earth system sciences
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5194/hess-30-7121-2026
Citations
1
Primary Topic
Hydrology and Watershed Management Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
1.18

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Process diagnostics of snowmelt runoff in global hydrological and land surface models – Part 2: Are more complex models better?

K. Zheng, Haomei Lin, Xiangyong Lei, Peirong Lin
1 citations
Hydrology and earth system sciences
Hydrology and Watershed Management Studies
1.18
article

Process diagnostics of snowmelt runoff in global hydrological and land surface models – Part 2: Are more complex models better?

K. Zheng, Haomei Lin, Xiangyong Lei, Peirong Lin
article en
1 citations

Abstract

The added value of increased process complexity has long been a central yet unresolved question in hydrological modeling, particularly for snowmelt runoff (SMR), where multiple physical processes interact in complex ways. In this study, we develop a Tree-Based Model Complexity Scoring (TBMCS) method to quantify the complexity of snow-related processes across 13 global hydrological and land surface models. We then systematically revisit the important linkage between model complexity and model performance in three distinct SMR characteristics, i.e., total runoff ( Q sum ), peak flow ( Q max ), and centroid timing (CTQ) of runoff in the snowmelt period. Further, we assess how the basin complexity (as delineated by 1455 snow-dominated basins), forcing difference and calibration status can modulate this linkage. Results show that (1) models differ substantially in their physical process representations, with the largest divergence in melting process treatments, followed by sublimation, interception and rainfall-snowfall partitioning processes. (2) Model performance for Q sum and Q max shows only weak associations with model complexity. Interestingly, we find a positive correlation between snow-process complexity and model performance for CTQ ( r =0.32). This relationship remains positive under high basin complexity ( r =0.35) and becomes statistically significant within the subgroup of models driven by GSWP3–W5E5 ( r =0.81, P <0.05). These findings suggest that greater snow-process complexity may be associated with improved simulation of runoff timing. Finally, we also find that (3) model performance depends more on systematic and balanced representations of key processes than on model complexity alone. These findings suggest that greater snow-process complexity may be associated with improved simulation of runoff timing but not runoff magnitude. By providing a quantitative and process-traceable framework for assessing model complexity, this study helps identify which process representations are most relevant for improving SMR simulations under complex environmental conditions.

Hydrology and earth system sciencesVol. 30(22)
Peking University (CN)
National Natural Science Foundation of China, Yunnan Provincial Science and Technology Department, Beijing Nova Program, National Key Research and Development Program of China
Climate action
Openalex Percentile: Top 29%
Hydrology and Watershed Management Studies
1.18
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon