Integrating the Genomic Revolution into Newborn Screening: Current Challenges and Future Perspectives

In recent years, the development of new diagnostic technologies, such as tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) and next-generation sequencing (NGS), has caused a veritable revolution in the diagnosis of genetic diseases, reducing time, cost, and invasiveness associated with prior diagnostic techniques. While MS/MS laid the foundation for the development of numerous, usually institutionally based, neonatal screening programs, NGS has gained traction in newborn screening (NBS), primarily through pilot projects and private funding across different countries. As a result, the traditional Wilson and Jungner criteria have been supplemented by additional criteria, including considerations of equity and access, in response to emerging technologies. This review aims to provide an up-to-date overview of the global landscape of metabolic screening panels, highlight the major ongoing genomic screening projects, and outline the current models for integrating these two screening systems. Substantial differences exist across countries in the numbers and types of diseases included in national NBS programmes. In this context, Italy represents a prominent case, as its neonatal screening framework has seen significant expansion and development in recent years, reaching a particularly comprehensive metabolic screening panel. Nonetheless, a number of initiatives to incorporate genomic technologies into the NBS pathway are currently underway, primarily involving high-income countries. Nonetheless, unlike metabolomic-based NBS programs, no country has a government-mandated NGS program as first-tier testing for newborns. New evidence is emerging from ongoing models of integration of multi-omics approaches into NBS, including the use of AI and machine learning. Identifying the most appropriate system for this integration to reduce the false-positive and false-negative rates associated with both screening types, ensure more equitable access to screening, and facilitate faster access to treatment may represent a useful and foresightful way to conceptualize NBS in the future. This transitional phase should promote rigorous improvements before full-scale adoption.