Peptide Identity of Electrochemically Deposited Polyarginine: A Critical Assessment

This review examines the feasibility of electrochemical synthesis of poly-L-arginine (PArg) using repetitive cyclic voltammetry in neutral aqueous phosphate-buffered saline. Previous studies on electrochemical deposition of PArg onto different carbonaceous electrode materials are discussed with respect to the already reported mechanistic models. Some controversial interpretations are of interest, predominantly the formation of peptide bonds during the electropolymerisation of L-arginine. Several alternative anodic pathways are considered via the possibilities and limitations of ways of attaching L-arginine molecules to the electrode surface. Furthermore, the role of oxygen-containing surface groups is discussed, as this aspect has been largely overlooked in the context of L-arginine deposition, despite the O-terminating character of the electrode surface and its effect on the reactivity of the nucleophilic guanidine group in L-arginine. Also, the application of extremely high potentials around +2 V vs. Ag/AgCl/3 mol L−1 KCl is considered, as it can lead to the generation of reactive oxygen species that may interfere with or even govern the entire deposition process. Thus, the absence of such considerations may raise doubts about the peptide nature of the electrochemically assisted polymerisation of this basic amino acid. Finally, it seems that the identity of the electrochemically synthesised PArg does not correspond to that of this polymer prepared by conventional methods, such as solid-phase peptide synthesis, solution-phase synthesis, or N-carboxy-anhydride polymerisation, and therefore the whole process remains unproved.