Analysis of Wear Behavior Between Tire Rubber and Silicone Rubber

Vulcanized NR-SBR is widely used in vehicle components; however, its irreversible crosslinking limits recyclability and contributes to the large number of tires discarded annually worldwide, and in this context, this work presents an experimental comparative assessment of the tribological behavior of conventional tire rubber and silicone VMQ, motivated by a wheel concept based on a detachable tread aimed at improving durability and sustainability rather than proposing an immediate material substitution. Wear and friction behavior were investigated under abrasive and self-friction conditions using pin-on-disk testing with an abrasive counterpart representative of asphalt, supported by optical and scanning electron microscopy. The results show that NR-SBR undergoes severe abrasive and erosive wear, characterized by deep and irregular wear tracks, pronounced fluctuations in the dynamic friction coefficient, and strong sensitivity to load and sliding speed, particularly during the initial stages of track formation. In contrast, VMQ exhibits mild abrasive wear dominated by viscoelastic deformation, leading to shallow and stable wear tracks, lower friction coefficients, and significantly reduced material loss once the contact track is fully developed. These differences are attributed to the distinct mechanical responses of the elastomers, as the higher hardness and limited strain capacity of rubber promote micro-tearing and unstable material removal, while the high elasticity of silicone enables stress redistribution and stable contact conditions under abrasive loading. UV aging increases stiffness of rubber, resulting in reduced wear and friction, while silicone remains largely unaffected after 750 h due to the stability of its Si–O–Si backbone. Self-friction tests further indicate that smooth silicone sliding against rubber yields the lowest friction values, highlighting a favorable material pairing for detachable tread concepts. Factorial design analysis confirms material type as the dominant factor influencing both wear and friction. Overall, for the specific materials and operating conditions investigated, VMQ demonstrates higher durability, greater tribological stability, and improved aging resistance compared to NR-SBR, providing experimental evidence that supports its potential for long-life, more sustainable detachable tread applications.