Particle size and surface morphology of plant protein powders determine the sensory perception of grittiness in liquid matrices

• Plant protein powder particles were assessed in conditions relevant to liquid foods • The trend between instrumental particle size and its sensory perception is non-linear • Particle surface morphology was quantified using visual assessment of SEM images • Surface morphology determines the sensory perception for particles <200 µm (D90) • These results are valuable for developing plant-based liquid dairy alternatives Plant protein powders are used in liquid dairy alternatives, but their low solubility may cause gritty texture defects. We investigated the factors influencing the sensory perception of particle size in 18 commercial plant protein powders—chickpea, fava bean, mung bean, oat, pea, soy, and wheat—in heat-treated water dispersions at native pH or pH 4.5, conditions relevant to end applications. We measured particle size distribution using laser diffraction and compared it with a sensory assessment. We also used scanning electron microscopy to visualize particles and developed a unique method to quantify surface morphology attributes by visually grading images with a sensory panel, obtaining particle angularity, surface roughness, and heterogeneity characteristics. The results showed that sample preparation significantly influenced particle size distribution and there was no correlation between instrumental results in the dry and liquid state. Particle sizes (D90) in water dispersions at native pH ranged 75–375 μm, which increased to 73–493 µm at pH 4.5; soy and wheat particles formed large clumps of 1–2 mm. We observed a linear relationship between D90 and sensorially perceived particle size for particles over 200 μm. For smaller particles, the perceived sensory size was instead explained by particle angularity and surface roughness. Small, round, and smooth particles were imperceptible, while rough and angular particles of the same size were detected by the sensory panel. These findings emphasize the importance of both particle size and surface morphology in causing gritty textures, offering insights for improving plant-based dairy alternatives.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Applied Food Research
Published
2026-01-15
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.afres.2026.101699
Primary Topic
Proteins in Food Systems
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Particle size and surface morphology of plant protein powders determine the sensory perception of grittiness in liquid matrices

Sirli Rosenvald, A. Sats, Helen Vaikma, Aleksei Kaleda et al.
Applied Food Research
Proteins in Food Systems
article

Particle size and surface morphology of plant protein powders determine the sensory perception of grittiness in liquid matrices

Sirli Rosenvald, A. Sats, Helen Vaikma, Aleksei Kaleda, Tiina Kriščiunaite, Kadi Jakobson
article en

Abstract

• Plant protein powder particles were assessed in conditions relevant to liquid foods • The trend between instrumental particle size and its sensory perception is non-linear • Particle surface morphology was quantified using visual assessment of SEM images • Surface morphology determines the sensory perception for particles <200 µm (D90) • These results are valuable for developing plant-based liquid dairy alternatives Plant protein powders are used in liquid dairy alternatives, but their low solubility may cause gritty texture defects. We investigated the factors influencing the sensory perception of particle size in 18 commercial plant protein powders—chickpea, fava bean, mung bean, oat, pea, soy, and wheat—in heat-treated water dispersions at native pH or pH 4.5, conditions relevant to end applications. We measured particle size distribution using laser diffraction and compared it with a sensory assessment. We also used scanning electron microscopy to visualize particles and developed a unique method to quantify surface morphology attributes by visually grading images with a sensory panel, obtaining particle angularity, surface roughness, and heterogeneity characteristics. The results showed that sample preparation significantly influenced particle size distribution and there was no correlation between instrumental results in the dry and liquid state. Particle sizes (D90) in water dispersions at native pH ranged 75–375 μm, which increased to 73–493 µm at pH 4.5; soy and wheat particles formed large clumps of 1–2 mm. We observed a linear relationship between D90 and sensorially perceived particle size for particles over 200 μm. For smaller particles, the perceived sensory size was instead explained by particle angularity and surface roughness. Small, round, and smooth particles were imperceptible, while rough and angular particles of the same size were detected by the sensory panel. These findings emphasize the importance of both particle size and surface morphology in causing gritty textures, offering insights for improving plant-based dairy alternatives.

Applied Food ResearchVol. 6(1)
Tallinn University of Technology (EE), Tallinn University (EE), Estonian University of Life Sciences (EE)
Openalex Percentile: Top 88%
Proteins in Food Systems
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.