Literature review on antimony concentrations in foodstuffs and consumer risk assessment

This study aimed to produce a comprehensive review of published data and Swiss enforcement laboratory analyses on antimony (Sb) concentrations in foodstuffs, including their sources, speciation, and potential health risks to consumers. Sb concentration data were compiled through an extensive survey of both scientific and grey literature. All data was critically evaluated, and only results supported by valid quality control procedures were retained and visualized. Food contamination with Sb may occur via environmental uptake (soil, irrigation water), processing, or leaching from Sb‐containing packaging (particularly PET). Total diet studies in multiple countries show generally low Sb levels in most foodstuffs, with higher exposures in infants due to their greater intake relative to body weight. Levels of Sb in most food categories are generally low with a few exceptions. Grains and grain products typically contain minimal Sb, while vegetables and legumes are usually low but sometimes present high outliers, particularly in leafy greens, dried onions and garlic, or mung beans. Fruits consistently show negligible levels, and beverages, including water and juices, are generally safe. Mushrooms can accumulate significant amounts of Sb and contribute substantially to the tolerable daily intake for frequent consumers. Sb concentrations in game meat are highly variable due to contamination from bullet fragments, which can pose a significant risk. Some dairy products, particularly whey, can approach tolerable intake levels for infants. Other categories such as meat, fish, eggs, herbs, and composite foods are mostly low risk, though occasionally high concentrations in spices and honey warrant attention. Using Swiss consumption data, cumulative Sb intake from all foods is estimated at 49 μg day‐1, representing 11.5 % of the World Health Organisation Tolerable Daily Intake (TDI) of 6 μg Sb kg bodyweight‐1 day‐1 for average consumers and 153 μg day‐1 (36 % TDI) for high consumers. However, these are upper‐bound estimates assuming maximum reported concentrations. Risk is negligible for most foods, but mushrooms, game meat, and certain dairy products can reach levels of concern for specific consumer groups. Our report highlights several knowledge gaps such as analytical methods for Sb that lack standardization, and high detection limits which hinder accurate comparisons across studies. Speciation data are scarce, limiting the ability to accurately assess the risk based on the more toxic trivalent form of Sb. There is a need for targeted monitoring of high‐risk foods such as mushrooms, game meat, and whey, as well as investigation into the sources of occasional high outliers in vegetables and legumes. Understanding whether contamination arises from environmental exposure, processing, or packaging is essential, and ongoing surveillance of Sb migration from food contact materials could inform future regulatory measures. We conclude that dietary Sb exposure in the Swiss population is well below health‐based guidance values, however, specific foods and consumer groups may face elevated risks.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Open Access CRIS of the University of Bern
Published
2025-12-23
DOI
https://doi.org/10.48620/93808
Primary Topic
Arsenic contamination and mitigation
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Literature review on antimony concentrations in foodstuffs and consumer risk assessment

Ursina Morgenthaler, Adrien Mestrot, Beat J. Brüschweiler
Open Access CRIS of the University of Bern
Arsenic contamination and mitigation
article

Literature review on antimony concentrations in foodstuffs and consumer risk assessment

Ursina Morgenthaler, Adrien Mestrot, Beat J. Brüschweiler
article en

Abstract

This study aimed to produce a comprehensive review of published data and Swiss enforcement laboratory analyses on antimony (Sb) concentrations in foodstuffs, including their sources, speciation, and potential health risks to consumers. Sb concentration data were compiled through an extensive survey of both scientific and grey literature. All data was critically evaluated, and only results supported by valid quality control procedures were retained and visualized. Food contamination with Sb may occur via environmental uptake (soil, irrigation water), processing, or leaching from Sb‐containing packaging (particularly PET). Total diet studies in multiple countries show generally low Sb levels in most foodstuffs, with higher exposures in infants due to their greater intake relative to body weight. Levels of Sb in most food categories are generally low with a few exceptions. Grains and grain products typically contain minimal Sb, while vegetables and legumes are usually low but sometimes present high outliers, particularly in leafy greens, dried onions and garlic, or mung beans. Fruits consistently show negligible levels, and beverages, including water and juices, are generally safe. Mushrooms can accumulate significant amounts of Sb and contribute substantially to the tolerable daily intake for frequent consumers. Sb concentrations in game meat are highly variable due to contamination from bullet fragments, which can pose a significant risk. Some dairy products, particularly whey, can approach tolerable intake levels for infants. Other categories such as meat, fish, eggs, herbs, and composite foods are mostly low risk, though occasionally high concentrations in spices and honey warrant attention. Using Swiss consumption data, cumulative Sb intake from all foods is estimated at 49 μg day‐1, representing 11.5 % of the World Health Organisation Tolerable Daily Intake (TDI) of 6 μg Sb kg bodyweight‐1 day‐1 for average consumers and 153 μg day‐1 (36 % TDI) for high consumers. However, these are upper‐bound estimates assuming maximum reported concentrations. Risk is negligible for most foods, but mushrooms, game meat, and certain dairy products can reach levels of concern for specific consumer groups. Our report highlights several knowledge gaps such as analytical methods for Sb that lack standardization, and high detection limits which hinder accurate comparisons across studies. Speciation data are scarce, limiting the ability to accurately assess the risk based on the more toxic trivalent form of Sb. There is a need for targeted monitoring of high‐risk foods such as mushrooms, game meat, and whey, as well as investigation into the sources of occasional high outliers in vegetables and legumes. Understanding whether contamination arises from environmental exposure, processing, or packaging is essential, and ongoing surveillance of Sb migration from food contact materials could inform future regulatory measures. We conclude that dietary Sb exposure in the Swiss population is well below health‐based guidance values, however, specific foods and consumer groups may face elevated risks.

Open Access CRIS of the University of Bern
Institute of Geography of the Slovak Academy of Sciences (SK)
Openalex Percentile: Top 36%
Arsenic contamination and mitigation
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.