Toward Integrated Computational Design: A Systematic Mapping of AAD–FEM Practices in Conceptual Structural Engineering

The early stages of structural design increasingly make use of computational tools that support rapid exploration, performance-informed decision-making, and closer interaction between design and engineering. This systematic mapping study examines how Algorithm-Aided Design (AAD) and the Finite Element Method (FEM) are applied and combined in conceptual design workflows. Based on a structured search across three academic databases and a coding scheme applied to 87 publications, the literature is mapped according to algorithmic strategies, FEM applications, element types, disciplinary domains, and levels of integration. The results show that algorithmic and predictive approaches are reported with increasing frequency after 2020, alongside growing use of surrogate models and optimisation routines. Linear-elastic analyses and shell- or beam-based models are frequently reported, particularly in civil engineering contexts, while nonlinear, dynamic, and solid-element analyses appear more prominently in mechanical domains. More tightly coupled AAD–FEM workflows become increasingly visible after 2021, reflecting a growing interest in real-time or near-real-time simulation feedback during early design exploration. At the same time, the literature highlights persistent challenges related to computational cost, fragmented toolchains, limited interoperability, and the relatively limited use of multiscale or advanced material models in conceptual design. Taken together, the findings suggest that continued progress toward more integrated AAD–FEM workflows is closely tied to advances in computational efficiency, improved data exchange and interoperability, and the development of more accessible design–analysis environments across disciplinary boundaries.