Assessing the Sustainability and Thermo-Economic Performance of Solar Power Technologies: Photovoltaic Power Plant and Linear Fresnel Reflector Coupled with an Organic Rankine System

In this study, the technical, economic, and environmental performances of a Linear Fresnel Reflector (LFR) integrated with an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), designed with a non-storage approach, and a monocrystalline photovoltaic (PV) system were comparatively evaluated in meeting a building’s 10 kW electricity demand. Solar-based electricity generation systems play a critical role in reducing carbon emissions and increasing energy self-sufficiency in buildings, yet small-scale, storage-free LFR-ORC applications remain relatively underexplored compared to PV systems. The optimal areas for both systems were determined using the P1–P2 methodology. The electricity generation of the LFR-ORC system was calculated based on experimentally measured thermal power output and ORC efficiency, while the production of the PV system was determined using panel area, efficiency, and measured solar irradiation data. System performance was assessed through self-consumption and self-sufficiency ratios, and the economic analysis included life cycle savings (LCS), payback period, and levelized cost of electricity (LCOE). The results indicate that the PV system is more advantageous economically, with an optimal payback of 4.93 years and lower LCOE of 0.053 €/kWh when the economically optimal panel area is considered. On the other hand, the LFR-ORC system exhibits up to 35% lower life-cycle CO2 emissions compared to grid electricity under grid-connected operation (15.86 tons CO2-eq for the standalone LFR-ORC system versus 50.57 tons CO2-eq for PV over 25-year lifetime), thus providing superiority in terms of environmental sustainability. In this context, the study presents an engineering-based approach for the technical, economic, and environmental assessment of small-scale, non-storage solar energy systems in line with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDG 7: Affordable and Clean Energy and SDG 13: Climate Action) and contributes to the existing literature.