Addressing the psychological burden: the case for resilience in medical training
To the Editor, A lot of people know about the problem in Pakistan, but not many people talk about it: medical students are under a lot of psychological stress. The hard classes, fierce rivalry, and high expectations from society all make academic stress common and even required for success. Because of this, we need to look more closely at the psychological features we search for in medical students. People often admire attributes like grit, but in a circumstance like this, where the stakes are great, their significance may be more complicated than we believe. This means we need to put more effort into making students stronger so that they can defend their health and the healthcare system in the long run. This article is compliant with the TITAN Guidelines 2025 governing the declaration and use of artificial intelligence tools in research and publication[1]. People frequently argue that having “grit,” which is having the desire and tenacity to reach long-term goals, is a key to success. But when it comes to medical education in Pakistan, putting too much emphasis on grit could have bad outcomes that weren’t meant to happen. Gritty students may set very high goals for themselves and keep going through pain and fatigue until they reach the point of burnout. This relentless desire, together with not having adequate skills to deal with stress, can make mental stress worse. New studies reveal that grit can help people accomplish well, but it doesn’t necessarily keep them from getting hurt mentally in a stressful situation. It can even be linked to unhealthy perfectionism at times[2]. On the other hand, resilience seems to be a more crucial feature that protects people. This means being able to change and get back on your feet after hard times. It’s not enough to only get through hard times; you also have to do it successfully. For medical students, this involves learning how to handle stress, keep things in perspective, and ask for support when they need it. Studies have shown time and time again that trainees who are more resilient feel less stressed and do better mentally when they are under a lot of academic and clinical strain[3]. We shouldn’t strive to help students deal with stress better. Instead, we should try to make them stronger so they can deal with it in a good way. It’s also vital to know that stress doesn’t affect everyone in the same way. Studies generally find that girls and students in their first and third years of school, which are transitional years, feel more academic stress. This suggests that there are institutional and curricular issues that make things harder for some groups[4]. This suggests that the organization has to make adjustments instead of merely telling the kid to “be tougher.” Some examples of interventions that have been demonstrated to relieve stress and promote well-being in similar contexts are mindfulness training, peer support groups, and mental health facilities that are easy to go to[5]. In the end, we want Pakistan to change how it teaches medicine. It’s crucial to accomplish well in school and keep going, but not if it hurts your mental health. Medical schools ought to stop rewarding people for putting up with suffering and instead encourage people to be strong. By combining research-based wellness programs with a supportive learning environment, we can make sure that we are producing doctors who are not only competent but also healthy, strong, and caring for future generations.
Authors
- Aman Shah (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5171-8651)
- Fnu Shahzaib
- Zarmina Inayat
- Arifa Arifa
Institutions
- Bolan University of Medical and Health Sciences (PK)
- GIFT University (PK)
- B.P. Koirala Institute of Health Sciences (NP)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Annals of Medicine and Surgery
- Published
- 2025-11-11
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1097/ms9.0000000000004280
- Primary Topic
- Grit, Self-Efficacy, and Motivation
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00