From bottleneck to boom: Polyploidy, genetic instability and response to artificial selection resolve the peanut paradox

This study, the second in a three-part series, shows how peanut's polyploid origin enabled rapid diversification and enhanced domestication potential. Building on the knowledge that cultivated peanut (Arachis hypogaea) originated from a narrow hybridization between Arachis duranensis and Arachis ipaënsis less than 10 000 years ago, we are confronted with a paradox: how did such a narrow origin give rise to so much diversity-two subspecies, six botanical varieties, and thousands of landraces differing in growth habit, seed size, and pod morphology? Although several diploid Arachis species were cultivated earlier, only the allotetraploid became fully domesticated and widely adopted. The global success of peanut, despite its narrow genetic origin, suggests that polyploidization itself facilitated domestication. To test this hypothesis, we investigated how the two diploid progenitors and neoallotetraploids derived from a single hybridization and polyploidization event responded under artificial selection. In a pollinator-free greenhouse, we advanced lineages of the neoallotetraploid and its diploid parents over 6 years, selecting for divergent seed weights. The neoallotetraploid showed a much stronger response to artificial selection than its diploid parents, while also spontaneously generating diverse phenotypic variation-including flower color, pod reticulation, and chlorophyll content-traits that distinguish A. hypogaea subspecies and landraces. These traits mirrored directional shifts in parental genome dosage caused by homoeologous exchange, supporting a causal connection with phenotype. These findings offer a compelling rationale for a domestication advantage in polyploid peanut, and provide a living demonstration of how a single ancestral tetraploid, despite an extreme genetic bottleneck, generates a phenotypic boom.