Understanding the Role of Base in Catalytic Transfer Hydrogenation: A Comparative Review

Catalytic transfer hydrogenation (CTH) provides a practical and sustainable approach for reducing unsaturated compounds, serving as an alternative to high-pressure H₂ in laboratory and fine chemical contexts. This broad reaction class includes asymmetric transfer hydrogenation (ATH), a key strategy in enantioselective synthesis due to its operational simplicity, high stereocontrol, and compatibility with sensitive functional groups. A central variable governing CTH efficiency is the role of bases, which may function as essential activators, co-hydrogen donors, or be entirely absent depending on the catalytic system. This review provides a comparison of base-assisted, base-free, and base-as-co-hydrogen-donor CTH methodologies across diverse metal catalysts and substrates. We highlight how bases such as triethylamine, K₂CO₃, and NaOH facilitate catalyst activation, modulate hydride formation, and tune reactivity and selectivity. The dual function of bases in formic-acid-driven systems is examined alongside synergistic effects observed with mixed-base additives. In contrast, base-free CTH platforms demonstrate how tailored ligand frameworks, metal-ligand cooperativity, and engineered surface basicity can eliminate the need for external additives while maintaining high activity. Through mechanistic analysis and cross-system comparison, this review identifies the key structural, electronic, and environmental factors that differentiate base-assisted from base-free pathways. Emerging trends-including greener hydrogen donors, advanced catalyst architectures, and additive-minimized protocols-are discussed to guide future development of sustainable CTH processes.