Visibility of Vertical Road Signs in Real Driving Environments: Effects of Retroreflectivity and Surface Conditions

The visibility of vertical road signs is a crucial factor for driving safety, especially in low-light conditions. The retroreflectivity of signs is imperative to ensure that drivers are able to perceive the information in a timely manner. However, the effectiveness of signs can be compromised by factors such as material degradation, wear and tear, and dirt on the surface. The objective of this study is to analyze how different surface conditions and different levels of retroreflectivity of vertical signs affect users’ perception and driving behavior in a real controlled environment. A total of twenty-five volunteers undertook the same road test twice. During the initial trial, the subjects encountered signs with a Class II retro-reflective film (EN 12899-1:2007), and during the second trial, they encountered the same signs in the same positions as the first trial but with varied characteristics and additional factors such as dirt, water, and degradation. Through a Mobile Eye Tracker and a Racelogic Video Vbox, it was possible to investigate the alterations in the visual and kinematic behavior of participants across the two tests. The statistical analysis was conducted using the Wilcoxon test, Spearman’s correlation and regression analysis. The analysis revealed that the signal with a dirty surface had the most significant impact on participants’ perception, showing a substantial reduction in the distance of the first fixation (−15%), a decrease in the number of fixations (−37%), and an increase in the time required for it to be perceived (+40%). This study demonstrates that the maintenance of road sign surfaces is a critical factor in their effectiveness and is as influential as the level of retroreflectivity of the material.