Peer review Nuclear and Astroparticle Physics with Large-Volume Neutrino Observatories Marco Selvi INFN Bologna

The manuscript entitled “Nuclear and Astroparticle Physics with Large-Volume NeutrinoObservatories”, authored by M. Selvi et al. (INFN Bologna), is not suitable for publicationin any APS journal.The submission does not contain the elements of a scientific article: no theory, no derivation,no quantitative analysis, no falsifiable predictions, and no physical framework groundedin first principles. The manuscript reads as an institutional overview or seminar material,not as research.For these reasons, I recommend Reject.