Reframing the Hard Problem of Consciousness
This preprint proposes a structural resolution to the Hard Problem of Consciousness (HPC) by identifying a category error at its core. Rather than attempting to derive subjective experience from physical processes, the framework clarifies the distinct roles of ontology, structure, and representation. The paper introduces the C-constant, representing ontological consciousness as an invariant condition of illumination, and the I–S–R model, which distinguishes illumination (I), structural mediation (S), and representational experience (R). Within this framework, neuroscience is reinterpreted as explaining how experiences are shaped, without claiming to generate consciousness itself. By dissolving the assumption that matter produces consciousness, the explanatory gap underlying the HPC is shown to arise from conceptual misclassification rather than empirical insufficiency. The framework preserves the explanatory power of physics and neuroscience while avoiding reductionism, idealism, and metaphysical inflation. A non-doctrinal comparison with Vedantic epistemology is included as an epistemic analogy, not a theological claim. This work is intended as a conceptual clarification within philosophy of mind and philosophy of science rather than an empirical hypothesis. This paper addresses the Hard Problem of Consciousness via the I–S–R framework. It introduces the C₀ (Consciousness Constant) as the existential ground of illumination and the I–S–R model to structurally decompose experience into Illumination, Structure, and Representation. The framework preserves both scientific integrity and Vedantic insight without introducing metaphysical excess or causal assumptions. Version 2 includes an Author’s Clarification Note formally establishing the canonical, non-operational interpretation of C₀ and the observational-only role of the I-layer.
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2025-12-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17963620
- Primary Topic
- Embodied and Extended Cognition
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00