SoK: Time to be Selfless?! Demystifying the Landscape of Selfish Mining Strategies and Models

Selfish mining attacks present a serious threat to Bitcoin security, enabling a miner with less than 51% of the network hashrate to gain higher rewards than their fair share. A growing body of works has studied the impact of such attacks and presented numerous strategies under a variety of model settings. This led to a complex landscape making it hard to comprehend the state of the art and distill insights, gaps, and trade-offs.In this paper, we demystify the landscape of selfish mining in Bitcoin by systematizing existing studies and evaluating more realistic model adaptations. To the best of our knowledge, our work is the first of its kind. We develop a multi-dimensional systematization framework assessing prior works based on their strategy formulation and targeted models. We go on to distill a number of insights and gaps highlighting open questions and understudied areas. Among them, we find that most of the surveyed works target the block-reward setting and do not account for transaction fees, and generally consider only single attackers. To bridge this gap, we evaluate several existing strategies in the transaction-fee regime—so miner’s incentives come solely from transaction fees—for both single and multi-attacker scenarios. We also extend their models to include honest-but-rational miners showing how such adaptations could garner more performant strategy variations. Finally, we touch upon defenses proposed in the literature, and discuss connections between selfish mining and relevant incentivized/fee-driven paradigms.