What's Wrong with Local Living? Understanding Misunderstandings Through Consultation Responses to Scotland's '20 Minute Neighbourhoods' Guidance

The canals and canalsides in Birmingham are valuable pieces of infrastructure, representatives of the city's industrial past.In Digbeth, the branches of Digbeth and Grand Union canals have received a great deal of attention from local organisations of artists and craft makers who have implemented activities for their enjoyment and public use.Yet, the values and perceptions of these communities remain overlooked in urban regeneration policies affecting the area.This paper focuses on analysing the relational values formed by local stakeholders and regular users in the canals and how they can provide insights into current urban policy and planning.The research implemented a photovoice workshop with participants who live and work in these areas to identify elements of significance along the canals and their surroundings.Initial findings reveal a unanimous appreciation for the natural elements along the canal paths, including their 'wild', 'aesthetic', and 'natural' features characterised by lush vegetation and the presence of wildlife.These spaces, often dismissed as residuals, are celebrated for adding unique qualities to the landscape.The discussions explored themes of ownership and appropriation, which are crucial for understanding the management and stewardship of these waterways by different stakeholders, including major landowners like Homes England, HS2, and Birmingham City University.This research underscores the intrinsic value of canals to their regular users and the influence of significant property holders on access and usage rights.