Helmholtz boundary integral methods and the pollution effect

This paper is concerned with solving the Helmholtz exterior Dirichlet and Neumann problems with large wavenumber $k$ and smooth obstacles using the standard second-kind boundary integral equations. We consider Galerkin and collocation methods -- with subspaces consisting of $\textit{either}$ piecewise polynomials (in 2-d for collocation, in any dimension for Galerkin) $\textit{or}$ trigonometric polynomials (in 2-d) -- as well as a fully discrete quadrature (Nyström) method based on trigonometric polynomials (in 2-d). For each of these methods, we prove -- in many cases for the first time -- rigorous results about the fundamental question: how quickly must the number of degrees of freedom (the dimension of the approximation space) grow with $k$ to maintain accuracy of the computed solution? Importantly, we determine which of these methods suffer from $\textit{the pollution effect}$. That is, we address the question: must the number of points per wavelength $\to \infty$ to maintain accuracy as $k\to\infty$?