Development of a decision framework for matching farm dairy effluent management practices to soil and landscape risk features

The safe application of farm dairy effluent (FDE) to land has proven to be a challenge for dairy farmers and regulatory authorities throughout New Zealand. Poorly performing FDE systems can have deleterious effects on water quality because contaminants such as phosphorus, nitrogen and faecal microbes enter receiving waters with minimal attenuation by soil. We present a decision framework that supports good management of effluent, particularly during its application to land. The framework considers how FDE management can be tailored to account for soil and landscape features of a location that pose varying levels of contaminant transport risk. High risk soils and landscapes are vulnerable to direct losses via preferential and/or overland flow pathways and include sloping land (e.g. slopes greater than 7 degrees) and soils with mole drainage, coarse structure, poor natural drainage or low surface infiltration rates. Soil types that are well-drained with fine structure typically exhibit matrix flow characteristics and represent a relatively low risk of direct contaminant loss following FDE application. Our framework provides guidance on FDE application timings, rates and depths to different landform and soil types so that direct losses of contaminants to water are minimal and the opportunity for plant uptake of nutrients is enabled. Some potential limitations for using the framework include the potentially severe effects of animal treading damage during wet conditions that can reduce soil hydrological function and consequently increase the risk of overland flow of applied FDE. The spatial distribution of such treading damage should be considered in the framework’s application. Another limitation is our limited understanding of the effects of soil hydrophobicity on FDE infiltration and application of the framework.