Lopsided distribution of MATLAS and ELVES dwarf satellite systems around isolated host galaxies

The properties of satellite dwarf galaxies provide important empirical insights for verifying cosmological models on galaxy scales. Their phase-space correlations, in particular, offer interesting insights into a broad range of models, since they are dominated by gravity and are largely independent of the specific dark matter flavor or baryonic processes that are considered. Next to the much-debated planes-of-satellites phenomenon, the lopsided distribution of satellites relative to their host galaxy has been studied observationally and in cosmological simulations. The degree to which observed lopsidedness is consistent with expectations from simulations is still unclear. We quantified the level of lopsidedness in isolated observed satellite systems under six different metrics. We studied 47 systems from the MATLAS survey beyond the local volume (LV) as well as 21 LV satellite systems from the ELVES survey. The satellite systems are complete to an estimated absolute magnitude of M ∼ −9. We find that the so-called wedge metric, counting the number of dwarfs in wedges with varying opening angles, is best suited to capture a system’s overall lopsidedness. Under this metric, our analysis reveals that ∼16 percent of the tested satellite systems exhibit a statistically significant degree of lopsidedness when compared to systems with randomly generated satellite position angles. This presents a notable excess over the expected 5% (2σ level) of significantly lopsided systems in a sample with no overall inherent lopsidedness. To gain the most rounded picture, however, a combination of metrics that are sensitive to different features of lopsidedness should be used. Combining all tested metrics, the number of significantly lopsided systems increases to ∼21 percent. Contrary to recent results from the literature, we find more lopsided systems among the red early-type galaxies in the MATLAS survey compared to the mostly blue late-type hosts in ELVES. We further find that satellite galaxies at larger distances from the host, potentially recently accreted, are likely the primary contributors to the reported excess of lopsidedness. Our results set the groundwork that allows a comparison with similar systems in cosmological simulations to assess the consistency with the standard model.