Patriotism and Esprit de Corps in Battle of Chosin Reservoir - as a "psychology of groups" and a form of social consciousness.- a refutation of Allport's 1927 taboo - "There is no psychology of groups " + 9 antisocial behaviors - a social meltdown?

The Battle of Chosin Reservoir during the Korean War is perhaps the hardest fought battle in American history. "On 27 November 1950, the Chinese force surprised the US X Corps commanded by Major General Edward Almond at the Chosin Reservoir area. A brutal 17-day battle in freezing weather soon followed. Between 27 November and 13 December, 30,000 United Nations Command troops (later nicknamed "The Chosin Few") under the field command of Major General Oliver P. Smith were encircled and attacked by about 120,000 Chinese troops." "We're surrounded. Good, that simplifies the problem……we're not retreating, we're attacking in a different direction." Chesty Puller Chosin Reservoir Esprit de Corps vs Allport's 1927 taboo, "There is no psychology of groups" As Claudia Nielsen pointed out, the psychiatrist McGilChrist astutely observed that "The scope of inquiry and understanding of the Materialist Doctrine with its rigid adherence to the actually arbitrary principle of quantification and over-emphasis on physiological characteristics is severely restricted and limited in the analyses that can be performed." An excellent example of this severely restricted protocol would be - as Kay Deux, a social psychologist points out the fixation of social psychology on laboratory experiments precludes "affective displays" and emotions. Kay Deaux, a prominent social psychologist, highlights the significance and importance of emotions especially in understanding many social, political or group related behaviors. Kay Deaux, emphasizes the fact that social psychology has historically had an "emphasis on experimenter-created social groups" which "precluded most affective displays." Experiments conducted in a laboratory would necessarily have a contrived and arbitrary aspect to them – very limited - and in that environment, cognitive concepts, structures and paradigms tend to be nice, neat, and precise constructs that are measurable in some sense. Kay Deux goes on to emphasize that "In contrast, natural groups, whether family, fraternity, or nation, are often the arena for intense displays of emotion and strong affective ties." (p. 794 Social Psychology Handbook of Basic Principles edited by E. Tory Higgins and Arie W. Kruglanski) That is, the Materialist Doctrine - Ideology excludes some facts, information and evidence due to the fixation on physiological quantification.

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Knowledge Commons (Lakehead University)
Published
2025-04-25
DOI
https://doi.org/10.17613/xrxqb-j6003
Primary Topic
Psychology of Social Influence
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Patriotism and Esprit de Corps in Battle of Chosin Reservoir - as a "psychology of groups" and a form of social consciousness.- a refutation of Allport's 1927 taboo - "There is no psychology of groups " + 9 antisocial behaviors - a social meltdown?

Knowledge Commons (Lakehead University)
Psychology of Social Influence
article

Patriotism and Esprit de Corps in Battle of Chosin Reservoir - as a "psychology of groups" and a form of social consciousness.- a refutation of Allport's 1927 taboo - "There is no psychology of groups " + 9 antisocial behaviors - a social meltdown?

article en

Abstract

The Battle of Chosin Reservoir during the Korean War is perhaps the hardest fought battle in American history. "On 27 November 1950, the Chinese force surprised the US X Corps commanded by Major General Edward Almond at the Chosin Reservoir area. A brutal 17-day battle in freezing weather soon followed. Between 27 November and 13 December, 30,000 United Nations Command troops (later nicknamed "The Chosin Few") under the field command of Major General Oliver P. Smith were encircled and attacked by about 120,000 Chinese troops." "We're surrounded. Good, that simplifies the problem……we're not retreating, we're attacking in a different direction." Chesty Puller Chosin Reservoir Esprit de Corps vs Allport's 1927 taboo, "There is no psychology of groups" As Claudia Nielsen pointed out, the psychiatrist McGilChrist astutely observed that "The scope of inquiry and understanding of the Materialist Doctrine with its rigid adherence to the actually arbitrary principle of quantification and over-emphasis on physiological characteristics is severely restricted and limited in the analyses that can be performed." An excellent example of this severely restricted protocol would be - as Kay Deux, a social psychologist points out the fixation of social psychology on laboratory experiments precludes "affective displays" and emotions. Kay Deaux, a prominent social psychologist, highlights the significance and importance of emotions especially in understanding many social, political or group related behaviors. Kay Deaux, emphasizes the fact that social psychology has historically had an "emphasis on experimenter-created social groups" which "precluded most affective displays." Experiments conducted in a laboratory would necessarily have a contrived and arbitrary aspect to them – very limited - and in that environment, cognitive concepts, structures and paradigms tend to be nice, neat, and precise constructs that are measurable in some sense. Kay Deux goes on to emphasize that "In contrast, natural groups, whether family, fraternity, or nation, are often the arena for intense displays of emotion and strong affective ties." (p. 794 Social Psychology Handbook of Basic Principles edited by E. Tory Higgins and Arie W. Kruglanski) That is, the Materialist Doctrine - Ideology excludes some facts, information and evidence due to the fixation on physiological quantification.

Knowledge Commons (Lakehead University)
The Centers (US)
Reduced inequalities
Openalex Percentile: Top 47%
Psychology of Social Influence
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.