Phosphorus Fractionation of Dairy Processing Waste Recycled Fertilizers Reveals Inadequacy of the Standards, Measurement and Testing (SMT) Protocol

The Standards, Measurements and Testing (SMT) protocol is widely used to fractionate phosphorus (P); however, it lacks the focus on defining the solubility of P-fractions, which is usually performed independently. In this paper, the addition of a separate pre-wash step with H₂O as a first step prior to the SMT protocol was tested to account for the solubility of P. Results were compared to a control unmodified SMT experiment. The differences in P-fractions were analyzed to determine the origin of the readily available P (soluble P). Six different dairy processing waste treatment products were investigated in the form of sludge, hydrochar, and ash. Water-soluble P (WSP) was correlated with weakly bound calcium (Ca), aluminum (Al) and iron (Fe). However, the SMT protocol failed to correctly identify the different pools of P as unexpected correlations were found between P and Ca, Al and Fe. Moreover, large concentrations of organic P were present in ashes (>10 mg P g⁻¹). The organic P fraction included substantial amounts of Fe that correlated highly with P (R² = 0.84). No association between WSP and any of the pools of P defined by SMT was detected, with the exception of total P and inorganic P. The paper concludes that SMT erroneously classifies P into different discrete fractions across various recycled P-products with fertilizer potential. A critical reevaluation of the SMT protocol is recommended, by abandoning the categorization of P into discrete pools and switching to solvent-based categories referring to the chemicals used in each extraction. SMT fractionation protocol was modified to assess water soluble phosphorusThe modified SMT protocol was performed on 6 different P-recycled products (fertilizers)SMT protocol fails to identify correctly different fractions of phosphorusA critical reevaluation of SMT protocol is recommended SMT fractionation protocol was modified to assess water soluble phosphorus The modified SMT protocol was performed on 6 different P-recycled products (fertilizers) SMT protocol fails to identify correctly different fractions of phosphorus A critical reevaluation of SMT protocol is recommended