Favorable and Unfavorable Changes Brought to Psychiatry by the Exponential Increase of Women in Brazilian Psychiatric Practice, and Its Contrast with the Former Male Domination of the Field
This article, based on 42 years of teaching medical students and psychiatric residents, explores the progressive feminization and masculinization of psychiatric practice. Current statistics show a clear trend towards an increasing female presence in psychiatry, not only in numerical terms but also in terms of practice style, professional identity, and therapeutic approach. The text presents a technical description of the diverse consequences of feminization, including increased multiprofessionalism, delegation of psychotherapeutic and cognitive domains, reduced focus on psychopathology, and transformation of professional identity. Conversely, the article also discusses the risks and limitations associated with excessive masculinization of psychiatry, such as reduced empathy, commercial pragmatism, excessive pharmacological interventions, and ethical risks. These complementary tendencies are analyzed without value judgment but rather as structural, cultural, and clinical challenges for future psychiatric practice. However, it must be stated that the feminization of psychiatry by women has undeniably brought much more progress than problems. Among these advances, the most significant is the psychotherapeutization of patients and the expanded understanding of mental illness within a broader affective, family, and relational context, moving away from purely biological and mechanical models. This transformation is, in a way, comparable to the historical contributions that psychoanalysis once brought to psychiatry
Publication Details
- Journal
- OSF Preprints (OSF Preprints)
- Published
- 2025-01-01
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.17605/osf.io/jzsrw
- Primary Topic
- Gender Roles and Identity Studies
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00