Garnet Geochemistry of the Makeng-Yangshan Fe Skarn Belt, Southeast China: Implications for Contrasting Hydrothermal Systems and Metal Endowment

The Southwestern Fujian Region is one of the important Fe polymetallic metallogenic belts in China. The Makeng-Yangshan Fe skarn sub-belt within it contains several deposits that share a similar geological setting, mineralization age, and genetic type, yet exhibit significant differences in metal endowment. To investigate the poorly constrained factors responsible for these differences, this paper focused on the mineral chemistry of garnets associated with magnetite from the Makeng, Luoyang, and Yangshan Fe deposits within the sub-belt, employing in situ laser ablation-inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS) for trace element analysis. Our results reveal that garnet from all three deposits are andradite-dominated and features a chondrite-normalized REE fractionation pattern exhibiting enrichment in LREE relative to HREE, indicating crystallization from unified, mildly acidic fluids under high oxygen fugacity (fO2) conditions. However, both the Makeng and Luoyang garnets showed a strong positive Eu anomaly, whereas the Yangshan garnets displayed the weakest Eu anomaly among the three deposits, which can likely be attributed to the highest fO2 environment of the Yangshan deposit. Furthermore, garnet Y/Ho ratios and Y-ΣREE correlations demonstrate that the Makeng and Luoyang garnets crystallized in an open fluid system that were primarily of magmatic-hydrothermal origin with substantial external fluid (e.g., meteoric water) involvement, whereas the Yangshan garnet reflects a relatively closed fluid system that was predominantly of magmatic-hydrothermal origin with limited external fluid input. These geochemical differences have direct implications for exploration: the open-system Makeng deposit holds promise for Mo-W-Sn mineralization, as does the Luoyang deposit for W-Sn, whereas the closed-system Yangshan shows little potential for these metals. In addition, this study reveals that Pb and Zn concentrations in garnet are not reliable exploration indicators. Overall, these findings provide important mineralogical constraints on the factors controlling deposit scale and metal associations, thereby enhancing the understanding of regional metallogeny and guiding future mineral exploration.