Sustainable Reclamation of Post-Mining Areas in Poland: The Long-Term Effects of Soil Substitute Covers and Phragmites australis Plantations

Degraded post-mining landscapes require reclamation strategies that ensure soil stability, environmental safety and successful vegetation establishment. This study evaluated two soil cover systems applied between 2020 and 2025 on a mining spoil heap in Libiąż, Poland: a two-layer (TL) cover with a soil substitute layer and a multilayer (ML) cover incorporating additional insulating materials. Both covers were non-saline and mildly alkaline. The applied methods supported favorable soil conditions after five years, with stable organic matter (24.48–28.26%), nitrogen (4.5–4.9 g/kg) and phosphorus (1.5–1.6 g/kg) contents, while potassium decreased markedly (from 17.1 to 6.44–6.83 g/kg), likely due to plant uptake or leaching. Leachate analyses showed low concentrations of toxic metals and salinity-related ions, confirming the environmental safety and inert properties of the soil substitute. Vegetation assessments revealed differences between reclamation systems, with Phragmites australis exhibiting greater stalk length, plant density and biomass in the TL cover. Establishment costs were also substantially lower for TL (EUR 1.65/m2) than for ML (EUR 6.14/m2). These results indicate that soil substitute covers provide a safe, cost-effective and functionally efficient reclamation option that supports circular economy principles by reusing mining waste and coal combustion by-products, while Phragmites australis enhances vegetation development and overall reclamation success.